A Conversation for Ask h2g2

A Many Splintered Thing

Post 1

Biggy P (the artist phormerly known as phord)

Does anyone agree that A Many Splintered Thing is one of the best BBC Comedy-Dramas since Happy Birthday Shakespear?


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 2

Ishhara

I kind of agree but I think that the characters aren't very well delineated - you know they are kind of two dimensional.
I prefer Border Cafe (still no match for Preston Front) but that is because I met the guy who writes it and he is a sweety. smiley - blush


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 3

Biggy P (the artist phormerly known as phord)

Oh ! Preston Front now that was a good one.


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 4

Demon Drawer

It has a certain Ally MacBeal wackiness to it, linked with a British grittiness. The fact that the gay character is overweight, sloppily dressed and neurotic is also a very good sub-plot.


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 5

Dinsdale Piranha

Are still we talking about A Many Splintered Thing here? I enjoyed the pilot, but the series disappoints me strangely. It's as if it can't sustain a series, like Ali G. getting a full half hour rather than a spot in another show.

I'm going off Ally McBeal, too. It seems to be too 'Hey look at me, I do wacky things with people that I see in strange visions' and not enough of her life any more. I can't put my finger on how this differs from what it was before, but I don't mind if I miss it these days.


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 6

Mustapha

Luckily, David E Kelley agrees with you, Dinsdale, and the show is going to be retooled, to get it back to its "emotional core" whatever that may be.


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 7

Dinsdale Piranha

Oh, that's good. Billy and Georgia have just degenerated in to 'annoying'. How can two supposedly intelligent people who make their livings arguing everything from 5 different viewpoints not make themselves clear to each other?


A Many Splintered Thing

Post 8

Ishhara

And I am a little pissed off at the notion that a professional career woman like Ali can only be truly happy once she has a bloke - she is just starting to really hack me off! smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post