A Conversation for The Nearly but Not Quite 'Official' Peer Review Discussion Forum

What's the current line on EG titles?

Post 21

pailaway - (an utterly gratuitous link in the evolutionary chain)

The other side of this coin, is that now if you search 'francis bacon' you get 'the ghost chicken of highgate' causing the average reader to assume that the search engine had hiccuped and move on, which is too bad since the entry has a great deal to do with Bacon.

I think that whittling the title to fit the engine is as procrustean as it sounds and worse, too easily leads to a kind of bland uniformity.

As much as it galls me, I'm going to have to agree with Matt and even go so far to say that I did prefer the original title, even though it was his.

I think it'd be better to let the title get hammered on during PR and go with whatever the result is - within the limits of feasibility, of course, as I have no doubt that Matt would try to be unfeasible.

(smiley - tongueout)


What's the current line on EG titles?

Post 22

U168592

I have one thing to say about that.

smiley - tongueout


What's the current line on EG titles?

Post 23

Fizzymouse- no place like home




.... and it took you from the 29th November to think of that witty retort.smiley - rolleyes


I have one thing to say about that .... smiley - doh



smiley - tomatosmiley - tomatosmiley - tomato


smiley - mouse


What's the current line on EG titles?

Post 24

U168592

well, I haven't been well lately.

Plus I have a reputation to uphold.

And please don't waste perfectly good tomatoes on me. Here, have a bun and some lettuce and make a ham roll.


What's the current line on EG titles?

Post 25

Fizzymouse- no place like home


smiley - flansmiley - flansmiley - flan



or perhaps you'd prefer



smiley - snowballsmiley - snowball



smiley - mouse


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more