Director: Alfred Santell
Producer: Pandro S Berman
Based on a play by Maxwell Anderson
Starring: Burgess Meredith, Margo, Eduardo Ciannelli
Why is this movie interesting? Isn't it just another Depression-Era gangster film? Actually, no. It's an altered version of the visionary American playwright's blank verse drama. Also, it was based on the now-infamous Sacco/Vanzetti trial, so the play and movie are politically and historically important. It's also an opportunity to watch Broadway actors reprise their roles on film, so that we get to see what New York City audiences got to appreciate in 1935. All in all, this viewing is worth an hour and a quarter of our time.
Here is a bit of background.
Maxwell Anderson (1888-1959): Anderson was born in 1888 in Atlantic, Pennsylvania, which was only 56 miles (91 km) from Ida Tarbell's birthplace, and just as insignificant. You can't find these places today: they aren't even wide places in the road. But there was something about the isolation of northwestern Pennsylvania in the 19th Century that seemed to make bright children want to read everything they got their hands on. Anderson did. His father was a Baptist preacher, and the family moved around a lot. Anderson grew up to be a really successful, award-winning playwright. Some of his plays continue to be well-known, such as Barefoot in Athens (about Socrates) and Joan of Lorraine (about Joan of Arc and the basis for the Ingrid Bergman movie).
Alfred Santell (1895-1981): Santell was an unusual directorial choice for the adaptation of a high-minded blank verse play with social significance. He directed over 60 films, beginning in 1917. But most of them were Hal Roach comedy two-reelers.
Pandro S Berman (1905-1996): A prolific film producer, Berman was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. His father was general manager of Universal Pictures. Berman won the Irving G Thalberg Memorial Award in 1976.
Burgess Meredith (1907-1997): Burgess Meredith, born in Cleveland, Ohio, had an acting career on stage, screen, and television which spanned six decades. What he is most remembered for depends on the age of the one doing the remembering. During the Second World War, he made films for the US military, such as How to Behave in Britain. Postwar audiences appreciated his appearances in Rod Serling's The Twilight Zone. In the 1960s, teenagers loved him as The Penguin in the camp television version of Batman. He later became known for playing a boxing trainer in the Rocky films, cavorting among the Greek myths in Clash of the Titans (1981), and as a cantankerous grandpa in the Grumpy Old Men movies. But in the early 1930s, Meredith was known primarily as a Broadway stage actor.
Margo, or María Marguerita Guadalupe Teresa Estela Bolado Castilla y O'Donnell (1917-1985): Margo was a Mexican American actor and dancer. She married actor Eddie Albert in 1945, and was the mother of actor Edward Albert. She was a respected performer with progressive views, whose career was limited by political blacklisting. This is relevant to her appearance in Winterset, which is a dangerously progressive story.
Eduardo Ciannelli (1888-1969): Born in Ischia, Italy, Eduardo Ciannelli became a surgeon, but later changed careers and toured Europe as a baritone. He migrated to the United States in 1914. He was known both for his work in stage musicals and dramas, but he also appeared in nearly 150 films and television shows. He was an effective villain.
For more than six years the Sacco-Vanzetti case has been before the courts of Massachusetts. In a state where ordinary murder trials are promptly dispatched such extraordinary delay in itself challenges attention. The fact is that a long succession of disclosures has aroused interest far beyond the boundaries of Massachusetts and even of the United States, until the case has become one of those rare causes célèbres which are of international concern.
– Felix Frankfurter
In 1921, two Italians, Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, were convicted of murder during the payroll robbery of a shoe factory in Massachusetts in 1920. They were sentenced to death. The appeals process was unusually long and drawn-out for the time, because legal experts like Harvard law professor Felix Frankfurter (later a Supreme Court justice) didn't feel that the conviction was sound. They pointed to contradictory evidence. They also pointed to the prejudice of the judge and jury.
Judges and juries were likely to be predisposed against Sacco and Vanzetti in the 1920s for two reasons: anti-Italian prejudice and the 'Red Scare', or fear of anarchists and communists. Sacco and Vanzetti were members of an anarchist movement. Saying 'anarchist' in 1920 was about the same as saying 'antifa' in 2020: the term meant about as much, since there were a wide variety of political beliefs connected with the name. But the general public associated anarchists with violence and bomb-throwing.
The lawyers' appeals were in vain: in 1927, both men were executed by electrocution. Maxwell Anderson was one of those who believed that a serious injustice had taken place. He knew about the evidence tampering, the prejudice, and the judicial misconduct – all of which show up in Winterset.
The Play's the Thing
Now all you silent powers
that make the sleet and dark, and never yet
have spoken, give us a sign, let the throw be ours
this once, on this longest night, when the winter sets1
his foot on the threshold leading up to spring
and enters with remembered cold – let fall
some mercy with the rain.
– Winterset, Act III
Maxwell Anderson was very clever: he didn't write a docudrama about the Sacco/Vanzetti case. It wouldn't have been performed. Instead, he wrote a high-drama serious play with a Shakespearean ending. In the play, the son of an unjustly executed Italian anarchist falls in love with the sister of the witness who refused to exonerate his father. Both are killed by the real perpetrator of the crime. They die together in a hail of submachine bullets and blank verse.
The movie has a happier ending, so let's watch that instead. Besides, we don't have a time machine to go back to 1935, when Winterset was showing on Broadway. But we can go to the movies: Winterset is available for viewing on archive.org, or check your Youtube listings.
The Popcorn Version
Mio Romagna (Burgess Meredith) has returned to the unnamed town from which he was expelled as a child after the execution of his father and the death of his mother. In common with other hobos of the Great Depression era, he has worked his way from coast to coast and gleaned his education where he can. Now, at 17, he's bright, witty, and very bitter. He has returned because there might be news that would exonerate his father and restore his reputation. Like Sacco and Vanzetti, Bartolomeo Romagna (played in the film flashback by John Carradine) was an activist and anarchist, but no murderer.
Trock Estrella (Eduardo Ciannelli) has been paroled from prison. He has six months to live, as he has a terminal disease. This will not stop him from killing just about everyone in this film in order to keep them from revealing the truth: that it was he, and not Bartolomeo Romagna, who killed the paymaster.
Miriamne Esdras (Margo) is the daughter of a poor and badly frightened rabbi. Her brother Garth (Paul Guilfoyle) was a witness to the murder, but never came forward. The family are lying low, hoping that Estrella will not bother with them.
Miriamne and Mio meet. They dance to the music of Chekhov's barrel organ2. They fall in love, even after the Irish beat cop shows up and forbids such street frolicking. He also threatens to arrest Mio for being a smart-aleck.
Judge Gaunt (Edward Ellis (1870-1952)) is wandering about the town. His conscience bothers him about the Romagna case: was he misled by false evidence? Is his life of judicial rectitude a lie? He has lost his reason.
Eventually, all the principals connect and rehash the case. Judge Gaunt is finally convinced of the truth, but to whom does it really matter? The police gently take him home, because he is a public figure. Trock Estrella and his trigger-happy henchmen are killing off witnesses. Who will survive? And what role will the barrel organ play in the exciting ending? Watch and find out. Oh, and get a glimpse into the real 1930s.