A Conversation for Cheddar Cheese

Peer Review: A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 1

Ashley

Entry: Cheddar Cheese - A837632
Author: Natalie - U190181


Natalie is too shy to do this herself so she has asked me to submit this on her behalf. Being the gentleman that I am I agreed.

It is a great entry that does exactly what it says on the tin. Enjoy smiley - smiley


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 2

Trout Montague

Fantastic.

Blessed are the Cheese-researchers.

Dr Trout (pseudo cheese-monger)


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 3

Tango

Great entry! No reason to be shy! I think we just have to wait the customary 7 days...

Tango


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 4

McKay The Disorganised

... and associated workers in the dairy industry.


smiley - ok

(and I don't even like cheese.) smiley - bigeyes


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 5

Z

Love the article natile, no need to be shy at all. just one small point it might look a bit prettier if you put and around the paragraphs stop it looking all bunched up see..


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 6

Bagpuss

And don't leave a space before the footnotes - on my screen one of them got shunted onto the next line, which looks very weird. Can we have temperatures in Centigrade for us bairns, please?

Brilliant article. The only remaining question is how a bucket of milk left in a cave got heated, had stuff added to it, got ground up and then heated again. smiley - winkeye


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 7

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

An entry on cheese that's not by Dr Trout?

*Faints* ::THUD::


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

This is a good entry, but it needs a bit of tidying up.

You gives weights in lb and cwt. Would it be too much trouble to provide the equivalent in kg as well? And temperatures in Celsius?

You say "which is competitive with Netto". I have absolutley no idea what this means, so perhaps an explanation might be in order.

There are fair number of typos and places where it doesn't quite flow right. I know you won't mind me listing them all.smiley - smiley

cheddar cheese, as expressed by --> cheddar cheese is here expressed by
The distinct flavour --> The distinctive flavour
son,. --> son,
as buying bought --> as having bought
that weighted 11 --> that weighed 11
it's usually mature between --> it's usually matured between
Cheddar is ranges from --> Cheddar ranges from
yellow-orangey --> yellowy-orange

Move the phrase in brackets (at a farthing a pound...) to after the word 'substance'.

smiley - cheers


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 9

Z

Keep at it though this smells a lot like an edited entry to be...


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 10

Ormondroyd

Yep, this is surely en route to the Edited Guide. smiley - smiley

As has already been noted, the layout could be improved, beginning with spacing after all the headers. Also, this key sentence: 'According to local legend, creation of the original bit of cheddar was a happy accident, following the abandonment of a pail of milk (for safety, apparently; there must have been rampant milk-thieves stalking Somerset in those days) in the Cheddar Gorge caves, as you do.' is a bit convoluted and might usefully be simplified.

But that's the sort of thing we sub-editors can deal with very easily. smiley - ok


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 11

Henry

"The Wurzels (a sort of Radiohead for the '70s)," smiley - laughsmiley - laughsmiley - laugh

Hi Natalie, nice article (particularly liked the new word, 'pretendy'. Cheddar cheese is also stored at Wookie Hole, just down the road. The crew of 'Harry Potter' filmed some of the two-headed dog scenes down there, though for all you could see of it they would have been better off in a dark studio. Anyway, the point being that cheese is stored in caves because they're very thermally stable - they maintain a reasonably constant temperature in summer and winter. Which is why I found the explanation of the 'accidental discovery' at odds with the final recipe. Do you think someone was taking the p*ss? Or more to the point, leaving it?


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 12

il viaggiatore

Excellent article on this most cheesiest of cheeses!

Question: why is the supermarket stuff colored orange?


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 13

Mu Beta

How dare you compare the Wurzels to Radiohead?smiley - cross

That talentless bunch of wasters are nothing compared to the master of Scrumpy'n'Western.

*unsubscribes in disgust*

Nice Entry, by the way.smiley - ok

B


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 14

Gnomon - time to move on

Is Natalie too shy to make the changes we have suggested? Or even to comment on why she doesn't think she'll make those changes?smiley - smiley


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 15

Z

Well she hasn't left the building ... she's an italic apparently!


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 16

Trout Montague

Maybe she's just letting it mature.


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 17

il viaggiatore

No need to be shy Natalie. We don't bite... hard.smiley - biggrin


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 18

Spiff


Thetanthrope: are you sure you're not buying Wensleydale? smiley - biggrin


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 19

Mu Beta



B


A837632 - Cheddar Cheese

Post 20

Spiff


Frogbit says:

"the point being that cheese is stored in caves because they're very thermally stable - they maintain a reasonably constant temperature in summer and winter."

How good it is too here the voice of h2g2's own speleological specialist enlightening us on the cheese-maturing qualities of the West Country cave! smiley - biggrin

smiley - laugh


Key: Complain about this post