A Conversation for Suggested change to Peer Review Intro page

Well...

Post 1

caper_plip

Make it more understandable?smiley - smiley

Caper Plipsmiley - borgsmiley - tennisball


Well...

Post 2

Hoovooloo

Hi CP!

I hope you and WD are enjoying Wimbledon... how many of the top ten male seeds are out now? Six, is it? It's like the World Cup all over again... without the accusations of biased refs.

Anyway, you weren't supposed to comment YET! smiley - winkeye

This is an adjunct to my rather sniffy "How to Comment in Peer Review", which is currently in ... Peer Review. Check it out...

H.


Well...

Post 3

caper_plip

Hi H!

It's sickening. Almost all the people in my Keepage are either out, injured, or can't be bothered to play. I would cheer for Lleyton Hewitt if he wasn't such a git.smiley - smiley

I was thinking that there should be a guide for Scouts when picking entries in Peer Review. It seriously annoys me when a Scout recommends an entry without paying any heed to what has been said in the conversation thread (especially when you were the only person who replied in that thread and the entry was clearly not ready to enter the Edited Guide... ie an entry on a certain computer game with an oversized gorilla with a fixation on barrels and bananas...)

I've had my fair share of comments that are outright arrogant and consider the Researcher who tried their best to write an entry on a topicsmiley - grrsmiley - crosssmiley - steam You can guess that I've just replied to one...

How are you?

Caper Plipsmiley - borgsmiley - tennisball


Well...

Post 4

Hoovooloo

Very well, thanks - will you be at the meet?

I know what you mean about the commenters... have you checked out my entry "How to comment in Peer Review"? I had three or four real corkers in the same week, so I got it out of my system... it's in PR now smiley - winkeye

So, does our Timmy come under your Keepage, or what?

H.


Well...

Post 5

caper_plip

Wow! It's had lots of commmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmments...smiley - winkeye

Well, the person I posted back to hasn't replied... they deserved it... arrogant smiley - bleep

Tim's a part-timer in my Keepage. It depends how he feels on the day... and me I suppose... but Rusedski's annihilation of Andy Roddick was impressivesmiley - wow, though Roddick is in my Keepagesmiley - weird


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Suggested change to Peer Review Intro page

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more