A Conversation for History of Christmas Cake
Peer Review: A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Started conversation Dec 23, 2005
Entry: History of Christmas Cake - A6859092
Author: Cal Fortuneswell - U193866
I did take this out because I was told that these two entries A661051A6904226 covered this already, having now had time to read both entries, I don't think they do, although one does have a receipe for christmas cake
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Mina Posted Dec 23, 2005
"Twelfth Night is traditionally the last day of Christmas (5th January)."
I thought twelfth night was 6th Jan - 12 days after christmas?
This entry and A663617 do seem very similar - some history followed by a recipe. This has different info in, but really I think there should only be one entry. Have you thought about updating Shazz's entry instead?
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
Please read the old peer review thread F2886447?thread=1426112&latest=1
I had already asked paully about that one
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Mina Posted Dec 23, 2005
Well, thanks for the link to the old thread, but I can't see any message by Paully there. 
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Mina Posted Dec 23, 2005
That says it's ok if you avoid the info Shazz has used. This entry is almost identical in format, which is why I think an update is a better idea.
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
I fail to see why you think it's identical, when my entry is solely about christmas cake
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Mina Posted Dec 23, 2005
A663617
So is Shazz's. History & origins, followed by recipes.
I've emailed the Eds to ask for their opinion on this, as there's no point me arguing about it if they'll accept this.
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
sorry thats not one of them that I was shown
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Mina Posted Dec 23, 2005
Ah, sorry, I thought it was - this was linked on the page that you linked so.
Does this change anything?
A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail Posted Dec 23, 2005
Well I surpose it'll be comming out again 
this entry will think it's doing the okey cokey
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review: A6859092 - History of Christmas Cake
- 1: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 2: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 3: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
- 4: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 5: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
- 6: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 7: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
- 8: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 9: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
- 10: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 11: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
- 12: Cal - interim high priest of the Church of the Holy Tail (Dec 23, 2005)
- 13: Mina (Dec 23, 2005)
More Conversations for History of Christmas Cake
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."