A Conversation for Poitín - The Small Pot.

Peer Review: A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 1

Lash LeRue

Entry: Poitín - The Small Pot. - A5524120
Author: Captain LeRue - because *&^£ was hard to pronounce. - U801685

Not enough entries involving Ireland and alcohol. All I really need to know if maybe it isn't long enough, if it is too long it could get boring, if to short a bit of a let down.

Capt. LeRue


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 2

TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office

Only in your fourth sentence, where you mention the Royal Irish Constabulary, does it become clear that poitín is an Irish drink. This entry needs some polishing, but should make its way into the Edited Guide soon enough!

(That's if you're prepared to work at it. I feel like such a hippocrite! I haven't done anything to my entry in a month.)

TRiG.smiley - biggrin


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 3

Lash LeRue

Yeah probably should make that clearer.

smiley - cheers


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 4

BigAl Patron Saint of Left Handers Keeper of the Glowing Pickle and Monobrows

smiley - erm Is it Poitin... or potin (You've spelled it two different ways- consistently!

smiley - smiley


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 5

Gnomon - time to move on

It's poitín, not potín. The word is pronounce 'putcheen'.

It's "man in the pub", not "man in a pub".

as told to me by the proverbial 'Man in a pub'
-->
as told to our trusty Researcher by the proverbial 'man in the pub'


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 6

Lash LeRue

Right, sorry cleared that up.

smiley - cheers


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 7

McKay The Disorganised

smiley - ok
Should one happen to receive a small bottle - perhaps left behind by a relative after a visit, or accidently placed in your coat pocket whilst it was hanging up in the bar - then a small quantity should be placed on a saucer and lit.

If it burns with a blue flame - then drink some cautiously - any other colour - throw it away.



smiley - cider


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 8

Lash LeRue

I'll put it in smiley - winkeye


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 9

Lash LeRue

Rights its in and I gave you one of those new 'Contributer credit' doo whakeys so if it gets into EG you'll get some credit.smiley - ok


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 10

McKay The Disorganised

Thats very good of you. smiley - cheers

smiley - cider


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 11

Lash LeRue

smiley - ok


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 12

Lash LeRue

Anyone got any new ideas To get this out of PR purgatory.


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 13

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

Well, you don't need to use apostrophes to pluralize words, and that would be easy enough to fix. Just change day's to days, centre's to centres, etc. smiley - cheers


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 14

Lash LeRue

smiley - ok


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 15

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

I think the main thing that still needs some work here is the style. Right now, it reads a bit like an email to your friends -- you've used ALL CAPS in places, loads of exclamation points, quite a number of incomplete sentences, etc.

Now, that's not to say we'd like to see this read like some smarmy school report, but I do think something a bit closer to what you might read in an enjoyable magazine would hit the mark. Here's a list of the different entries we have in the Edited Guide about drinks, maybe they will give you more of a clear idea of what we're looking for -- <./>C259</.>. If this was to be picked now, a sub would have do to quite a decent bit of work making those changes -- and then it would be written more in the sub's style than yours, which just wouldn't be fair to either of you.

smiley - cheers
Mikey


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 16

Lash LeRue

okay dokay


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 17

Researcher 188007

Hi,

Just one thing: I feel you need to at least mention the usual spelling of the word in English, pocheen.

Jack


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 18

Gnomon - time to move on

I've never seen it spelt pocheen. The normal spelling in English is poteen.


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 19

Lash LeRue

Yeah, I've only seen it spelt Poteen as well.

*shrugs*

Oh well, I'll stick it in as a footnote.


A5524120 - Poitín - The Small Pot.

Post 20

Researcher 188007

No, completely wrong smiley - erm I must have dreamt it.


Key: Complain about this post