A Conversation for The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Merry Anne Posted Jan 27, 2009
Thank you.
I wondered about linking (at least to the quotes I included). After all, it's not likely that they'll be removed. Do you know of an entry where it has been done before?
I considered the h2g2 (and BBC-wide?) U16 user ban, I know some have left the site (and I'm not referring to the U16s here) because of it.
To be honest, without the Stretcher I would never have thought of writing an entry about this, and put it into PR at that.
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
U168592 Posted Jan 27, 2009
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
I can't think of any EG Entries that link to internal threads off the top of my head, sorry
Could go huntin' spose.
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Malabarista - now with added pony Posted Jan 27, 2009
The oddest example of this I've found is that while you can write nuts, you can't write "nuts" in quotes. (Unless this goes through, in which case it's been changed since it happened...)
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Noth€r Posted Jan 27, 2009
i found a thread A1070452
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Malabarista - now with added pony Posted Jan 27, 2009
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor Posted Jan 27, 2009
Was this in reference to General MacAuliffe?
General von Berlichingen, of course, is barred from these pages on the grounds of foreignness. As is that French Marshall, I forget his name...
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Malabarista - now with added pony Posted Jan 27, 2009
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Rudest Elf Posted Jan 28, 2009
"I've seen the PF referred to in conversations as the 'filther' though I can't remember which h2g2 worthy coined the term." I doubt that many would consider me to be an 'h2g2 worthy'
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Merry Anne Posted Jan 28, 2009
Thanks for the link, Rudi. I've gone back a bit to look for earlier mentions of 'filther', and I found this: A10606600
I've now added the following:
However, this being 'hootooAn endearment for h2g2.', one Researcher soon came up with a 'sewr word lexicon idea, the The h2g2 Profanisaurus. Even now (January 2009), people still post suggestions to it.
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Merry Anne Posted Jan 28, 2009
On which page? The swear words lexicon? It would only appear there if you posted suggesting it. And it's not really a swear word, or intended as one, is it?
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Tibley Bobley Posted Jan 28, 2009
I remember this tripping me up some time back. It was the paedo word but it took me a while to find that out. Got round it by replacing one of the vowels with an asterisk. It didn't seem to make much sense at the time. I can't remember coming across anyone effing and blinding on h2g2, but if they wanted to make sure that nobody did, why stop them discussing valid issues - like child protection?
A flipping good read, Anne. Well done
Nit picking seems an unwholesome habit, but no-one should notice if I'm quick:
>>There may well be some unspecific fear be the underlying reason for the strong dislike, though.<<
Could do with a little adjustment, and
>>An endearment for h2g2<<
Should that be "a term of endearment"?
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Merry Anne Posted Jan 28, 2009
Thanks for that, Tibley. Yes, I remembered the paedophile issue well. Funny thing was, you didn't even need the *, just omitting the 'a' did the trick. Maybe they wanted to force us to write the US variant?
I'll go and amend accordingly. It's annoying, the things you miss first while writing, then proofreading your own writing. You hardly ever miss them in somebody else's writing.
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Rudest Elf Posted Jan 28, 2009
Hi, Merry Anne!
I agree that 'filther' is not a swearword, and I am not suggesting that it is.
I claimed in Posting 30 to have been the one to coin the word, and challenged anyone to come up with an earlier example.
When you responded with, "I've gone back a bit to look for earlier mentions of 'filther', and I found this: A10606600", I thought you'd found an example, posted by another Researcher, predating mine.
You might have noticed that no one else has come forward to claim the honour.
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Merry Anne Posted Jan 28, 2009
Sorry for not making it clear, Rudi.
After I found the 'lexicon' I was too distracted to search any further. As far as I'm concerned, your claim is fine. I'm not surprised nobody else has spoken up, though, I don't think this is the forum to attract the masses.
Tibley: does it help?
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Rudest Elf Posted Jan 28, 2009
"I don't think this is the forum to attract the masses.
Oh, I don't know - you're attracting quite a crowd!
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
U168592 Posted Jan 28, 2009
*waves a placard*
What are we protesting about?
Key: Complain about this post
A46464500 - The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
- 21: Merry Anne (Jan 27, 2009)
- 22: U168592 (Jan 27, 2009)
- 23: Malabarista - now with added pony (Jan 27, 2009)
- 24: Noth€r (Jan 27, 2009)
- 25: Merry Anne (Jan 27, 2009)
- 26: Merry Anne (Jan 27, 2009)
- 27: Malabarista - now with added pony (Jan 27, 2009)
- 28: Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor (Jan 27, 2009)
- 29: Malabarista - now with added pony (Jan 27, 2009)
- 30: Rudest Elf (Jan 28, 2009)
- 31: Merry Anne (Jan 28, 2009)
- 32: Rudest Elf (Jan 28, 2009)
- 33: Merry Anne (Jan 28, 2009)
- 34: Tibley Bobley (Jan 28, 2009)
- 35: Merry Anne (Jan 28, 2009)
- 36: Rudest Elf (Jan 28, 2009)
- 37: Tibley Bobley (Jan 28, 2009)
- 38: Merry Anne (Jan 28, 2009)
- 39: Rudest Elf (Jan 28, 2009)
- 40: U168592 (Jan 28, 2009)
More Conversations for The h2g2 Profanity Filter and Offensive Words
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."