A Conversation for The Society Mansions of Newport, Rhode Island

Peer Review: A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 1

JulesK

Entry: The Mansions of Newport - A14539241
Author: JulesK - U649222

Hopefully this will be of interest: it's taken from the 'epic adventures of JulesK in the USA' , i.e. my summer hols smiley - winkeyesmiley - ok


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 2

steve-paul ---- no lyrics!!<wah>

very Interestingsmiley - ok

For a minute i thought it was about mansions in Newport, UK! i was a bit confusedsmiley - biggrin

SPsmiley - winkeye


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 3

McKay The Disorganised

Very Good Jules - but you do need to add Rhode Island to the title.

smiley - cider


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 4

Leo


ooh, a tantaliser... Can't you give any gory details? Like how many third world nations could have been industrialized with the cost of building one of those homes - or just throwing one party in it? smiley - winkeye

Alternatively, numbers of rooms, and their functions and other ostentations - one of the similiar mansions in Connecticut had a fountain under the stairs, I recall. The Vanderbilts wouldn't have been outdone by someone from Connecticut.


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 5

JulesK

I'll try to dig out a few more facts. As usual I like to write from what I've seen or been told as I don't ever want to be accused of copying stuff from elsewhere. However I'm sure a bit of research wouldn't go amiss smiley - ok


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 6

JulesK

A few nuggets added smiley - smiley


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 7

JulesK

*Takes a run up*

...smiley - boing

smiley - biggrin


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 8

JulesK

Any more suggestions from anyone? smiley - smiley


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 9

aka Bel - A87832164

Sorry, this dropped off my radar completely smiley - yikes

Will go and re-read smiley - run


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 10

aka Bel - A87832164

Ok, I'm back from reading it now. You say:
>>Unsurprisingly, the Cliff Walk doesn’t go past Hammersmith Farm.<<

Why is this unsurprising? Is it the last building before the cliff drops down? Or is it because it was the last of these houses that was built?


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 11

JulesK

It's because it belonged to JFK and is probably still in the family.


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 12

aka Bel - A87832164

But they're no longer presidents, are they? So I'd suggest you change the sentence to: The Cliff Walk stops at Hammersmith Farm.


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 13

JulesK

I've found out that Hammersmith Farm isn't owned by the Kennedy family anymore and have removed that sentence as it therefore makes no sense. A lot like me when typing this late smiley - winkeye


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 14

aka Bel - A87832164

Oh, good ( to be honest, it didn't make sense to me anyway smiley - tongueout )


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 15

JulesK

Well it did to me smiley - tongueoutsmiley - winkeye


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 16

JulesK

What do people think about the title?

I was wondering whether it didn't quite explain the subject matter, as you have to already know that these are specifically famous mansions. It might just read like 'The big houses of Rotherham', to which people might think, 'well so what, there are big houses everywhere' (even in Rotherham, which I only picked as an example because I was born there!).

Should there be another word before mansions? The famous mansions? The millionaires' mansions? A different title entirely?

Hmm...

Julessmiley - smiley


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 17

aka Bel - A87832164

Hmmm, now you ask: 'Millionaires' mansions of Newport, USA' or something might be a better choice.smiley - erm


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 18

JulesK

How about 'The High Society Mansions.....'?

The owners were known as Society. If I just put that it'll look like some club or other and the phrase 'high society' is well known.


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 19

JulesK

I think this is done now, as far as I'm concerned. Title sorted.

Thanks for the comment at the bottom of the Entry, Jaz'd smiley - ok

Julessmiley - smiley


A14539241 - The Mansions of Newport

Post 20

aka Bel - A87832164

Yes, glad you reminded me smiley - biggrin


Key: Complain about this post