A Conversation for The Forum
Middle East Crisis 2006
Effers;England. Posted Aug 14, 2006
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/4789083.stm
What a surprise. The Lebanese government are dithering about how to disarm Hezbollah. And the ceasefire is yet to start. What ceasefire I wonder?
This is something I keep banging on about. How exactly are Hezbollah to be genuinely disarmed? And who's going to do it?
Middle East Crisis 2006
Wilma Neanderthal Posted Aug 14, 2006
HA will give up their arms themselves, at least that it what they have said consistently for many many years, when their is no Israeli on Lebanese soil anymore (including Shebaa). I do hope this ceasefire holds...
Middle East Crisis 2006
Wilma Neanderthal Posted Aug 14, 2006
Thanks, Nick
************************
Overall the language from both sides suggests nervous times ahead, with both sides on tenterhooks, ready to pounce on anything they see as a ceasefire violation, says the BBC's Rob Norris in Jerusalem.
Mark Malloch Brown, the UN's Deputy Secretary General, told the BBC it might take a month before a joint UN-Lebanese force was fully in place.
But EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana suggested that the first international troops could be in place within the next week.
He told Reuters that European nations, notably France and Italy, were ready to send troops to the region.
Other countries, including Malaysia and Indonesia, which do not have diplomatic relations with Israel, were also willing to contribute troops to an international force, Mr Solana said.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4789569.stm?ls
Middle East Crisis 2006
WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. Posted Aug 14, 2006
I half heard on the Today programme this morning that America had sanctioned Israel to bomb Hizbollah as a precursor to bombing Iran.
Seems it is from Seymour Hersh of the New Yorker magazine. Scary stuff but would appear credible with the current American administration.
http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/2006/s1714570.htm
Middle East Crisis 2006
Blues Shark - For people who like this sort of thing, then this is just the sort of thing they'll like Posted Aug 14, 2006
Judging by the news I saw yesterday, Olmert has his own problems.
In the period since the latest hostilities began, his approval rating has dropped from 75% to about 45%, and less than 25% of the Israeli population believes the IDf are 'winning' (whatever that means in thses strange and troubled times) the 'war'.
The present crisis has been disasterous for the Israelis. Their much vaunted military machine (once considered to be the one 'super-power' of the middle east) has effectively been bogged down by a relatively small and badly equipped force.
Worse yet, it may have precipitated the first serious rethink in US foreign policy regarding Israel for the first time in many, many years. It's not yet come to anything, but I sense a growing unease in the State Department, who i suspect have no political will to see US involvement in the middle east beyond its present state). Israel hardly strengthened their position by undermining the PLO, presumably with the intent of getting a mora amenable Palistinian leadership and then acting suprised when Hammas was elected in free and democratic elections.
Middle East Crisis 2006
Wilma Neanderthal Posted Aug 14, 2006
Thanks for the link, WA... and here we all though Nasrallah was talking out of his robes last week He said something very similar - essentially that Israel was planning a campaign regardless - HA had information about this but they thought it was planned for Sept/Oct and did not expect this rection in July...
"SEYMOUR HERSH: Well, you know, normally, you'd think that there is a learning curve, but not in this White House. My own belief is that some of the people talking to me are also very nervous about the fact that they believe this White House is incapable of learning what it doesn't want to learn.
Right now intelligence is being cooked just the way it was cooked before the war in Iraq. There's intelligence about Iran and its ties to Hezbollah, which are certainly deep, but not as deep as the White House would believe from the intelligence it's getting. A case is being dealt in the intelligence community against Iran that may not be accurate. "
Doesn't imspire confidence, does it? Who is this Hersh person? I get very nervous when I hear the western press saying something so controversial... (other than Fisk of course, coz he's gone native, of course.. )
Middle East Crisis 2006
WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. Posted Aug 14, 2006
Well he doesn't seem to be a friend to Bush and the Neocons but he does seem to be a heavy hitter:
http://www.berkeley.edu/news/media/releases/2004/10/11_hersh.shtml
Middle East Crisis 2006
swl Posted Aug 14, 2006
Well, someone seems to have "won" anyway.
http://news.sky.com/skynews/article/0,,30000-1230763,00.html
Middle East Crisis 2006
Wilma Neanderthal Posted Aug 14, 2006
You obviously did not hear Ehud Olmert and Binyamin Netanyahu speak today, SWL
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/31DA80B0-A492-4CEB-8AF3-A252F7ADD2A2.htm
Middle East Crisis 2006
Arnie Appleaide - Inspector General of the Defenders of Freedom Posted Aug 14, 2006
here's my favorite line from the leader of Hizbullah:
"He said the "massive devastation and destruction" inflicted upon Lebanon reflected Israel's "failure and impotency""
Huh?
Middle East Crisis 2006
WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. Posted Aug 15, 2006
Well what does it represent then, a massive victory or wanton destruction of civilain infrastructure and, as I've argued before, if the Israeli claims to be pin point accurate with American laser guided bombs is correct, the murder of over a thousand innocent people including many children.
Look at the evidence or the facts on the ground. Runways bonbed, why? Power stations bombed, why? Oil storage bombed causing massive ecological damage, why? Apartment blocks bombed, why?
What has the IDF and the Israeli Airforce achieved apart from the abhorrence of the rest of the World except of course from America and its client states. And even they, via the Arab League, have come out in favour of Lebanon.
Hizbollah is now feted throughout Islam and has been handed the finest recruiting sergeant it could ever have wished for. Yes a great result.
Middle East Crisis 2006
Noggin the Nog Posted Aug 15, 2006
I also note that Olmert has said he will do "everything possible" to get back the two Israeli soldiers captured by Hizbollah. I assume that "everything" doesn't include simply exchanging them for the prisoners illegally held by the Israelis.
Noggin
Middle East Crisis 2006
Wilma Neanderthal Posted Aug 15, 2006
Olmert (in his Knesset speech) also said that they will pursue HA to the end with no intention of 'asking permission'.
Middle East Crisis 2006
Arnie Appleaide - Inspector General of the Defenders of Freedom Posted Aug 15, 2006
Wandering, it represents typical modern warfare. As has been stated by numerous people (not me), the Lebanese population supports Hizbulloh. Ergo, the generally unstated fact is that Israel is at war with Lebanon as a whole, not just Hizbulloh. In war, you target everything (especially civilian infrastructure) to defeat the other side. That's well established.
Runways bombed? To put pressure on Lebanon. Power stations bombed? To put pressure on Lebanon. Oil storage bombed? To put pressure on Lebanon. Apartment blocks bombed? To put pressure on Lebanon.
Key: Complain about this post
Middle East Crisis 2006
- 741: Effers;England. (Aug 14, 2006)
- 742: McKay The Disorganised (Aug 14, 2006)
- 743: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 744: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 745: Rev Nick { Only the dead are without fear } (Aug 14, 2006)
- 746: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 747: WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. (Aug 14, 2006)
- 748: Blues Shark - For people who like this sort of thing, then this is just the sort of thing they'll like (Aug 14, 2006)
- 749: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 750: WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. (Aug 14, 2006)
- 751: swl (Aug 14, 2006)
- 752: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 753: swl (Aug 14, 2006)
- 754: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 14, 2006)
- 755: Arnie Appleaide - Inspector General of the Defenders of Freedom (Aug 14, 2006)
- 756: WanderingAlbatross - Wing-tipping down the rollers of life's ocean. (Aug 15, 2006)
- 757: novosibirsk - as normal as I can be........ (Aug 15, 2006)
- 758: Noggin the Nog (Aug 15, 2006)
- 759: Wilma Neanderthal (Aug 15, 2006)
- 760: Arnie Appleaide - Inspector General of the Defenders of Freedom (Aug 15, 2006)
More Conversations for The Forum
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."