A Conversation for Lochranza Arran.

Peer Review: A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 1

reg/petro

Entry: Lochranza Arran. - A1140616
Author: reg/petro - U225598

A quick, explanation as to why I feel that Lochranza is such a great place to visit.


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 2

Cyzaki

smiley - yikes another one which nobody has commented on! How do they slip through then net?!

smiley - panda


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 3

Cyzaki

Can you split it up into paragraphs using s or s to make it easier to read? Or if you aren't used to guideml can you just put a line between each paragraph please?

smiley - panda


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 4

Kat - From H2G2

I agree. Paragraphing is DEFINITELY needed. I'll come back and read it when it's been split though. Currently I'm too lazy to actually read it as a block, sorry smiley - blush


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 5

Ausnahmsweise, wie üblich (Consistently inconsistent)

Hi,

I read it!

You will have to re-work the first person references. They are generally not allowed in editted guide entries. That's easily done.

I saw a few typos.

the islands distillery
public golf cause,
pop into wither the field centre or the youth hostel
there not wild (they're not wild)

And something's missing/mixed up here...
(the other geologist was a bloke called Matt Kennet, who I have now gone to the island for my dissertation work a total of three times)!

Awu.


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 6

Number Six

I agree with what basically everyone on this thread says, particularly Awu. I think with a little re-working, this should be an excellent addition to the Edited Guide.

I like good geographically based entries a lot, and would like to see more of them - when I first came to h2g2, I thought that's what the site would be all about, and was a bit surprised to find it a bit lacking in that department.

However, I also know that reg/petro tends to visit h2g2 quite spasmodically, so we may be in for a little wait for him to reply. When you do come back, reg/petro, it might be worth your while having a quick look at the Writing-Guidelines, particularly point 12 with regard to the first-person thing.

Also, I'd suggest changing the title to something like 'Lochranza, Isle of Arran, Scotland' - that fits in more with the kind of geographical classification used on h2g2, and will give passing researchers a little more of an idea what the entry's about.

smiley - cheers

All the best,
Number Six

smiley - mod


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 7

Cyzaki

You still here, reg/petro?

smiley - panda


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 8

Cyzaki



smiley - porkpiesmiley - crispssmiley - cheesecakesmiley - stoutsmiley - coffee

smiley - panda


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 9

Whisky

**wanders into the thread**

smiley - porkpiesmiley - crispssmiley - cheesecakesmiley - emptysmiley - coffee



smiley - cheers I was thirsty...



smiley - run


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 10

GreyDesk

Oi! Stop that smiley - cross


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 11

Whisky

smiley - blush

Whoops, smiley - sorry, got carried away there...

**wanders back in with a replacement glass**

smiley - porkpiesmiley - crispssmiley - cheesecakesmiley - ojsmiley - coffee


smiley - whistlesmiley - angel


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 12

GreyDesk

That is *not* the same as you well know smiley - grr


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 13

Whisky

smiley - sadface

Spoilsport smiley - nahnah

smiley - porkpiesmiley - crispssmiley - cheesecakesmiley - stoutsmiley - coffee



Happy now?


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 14

GreyDesk

That's better smiley - smiley


* drinks spare smiley - oj that he finds lying around *

smiley - run


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 15

Whisky

Oi! smiley - steam I paid for that!

smiley - run


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 16

GreyDesk

smiley - tongueout


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 17

Cyzaki

Well, the bait worked I guess, but it didn't attract the researcher I was after...

smiley - panda


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 18

Whisky

It did provide me with a little light relief though


smiley - winkeye


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 19

GreyDesk

...and me with a refreshing drink smiley - smiley


::burp::


A1140616 - Lochranza Arran.

Post 20

Whisky

And a face-full of flan...

CATCH!

smiley - flan


Key: Complain about this post