A Conversation for Neon Lighting

Pedantry rules :-P

Post 1

Orcus

But Neon and Argon are not molecular so strictly speaking there are no molecules in Neon gas - it is composed of unbound atoms as are all the noble gases, Helium, Neon, Argon, Krypton, Xenon and Radon. Mercury gas has Hg2 molecules though so that's OK.

Not that it really matters here smiley - winkeye

Nice entry anyhow smiley - ok


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 2

Just an innocent bystander

Ouch, where were you when this was going through Peer Review ? smiley - erm
Could have saved me from this mistake. Thanks for pointing it out, though.

Glad you liked the rest.

JAIB


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 3

Orcus

Sorry, missed its trip through PR I'm afraid.

Hey, don't worry about it, only pedantic chemists like myself will even notice smiley - winkeye

I liked it because I didn't know before how it was all done. Now I do. That, after all, is the purpose.

smiley - cheers

Orcus


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 4

Just an innocent bystander

Well, what would become of H2G2 if it weren't for pedantic chemists (and other knowledgeable folks) ? smiley - smiley

Thanks again,

JAIB


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 5

Ashley


Can you indicate which parts I should change and I'll do it straight away?

smiley - cheers


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 6

Orcus

I think if a footnote is added after the molecules link to the effect of "It should be noted that generally gases are made up of molecules but strictly speaking pure argon and neon are not molecular but consist of free atoms.", then that would suffice smiley - smiley Or words to that effect anyway.

Orcus


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 7

Just an innocent bystander

Hi Ashley, thanks for noticing so quickly. smiley - ok

I would agree with Orcus, otherwise you would lose that nice "molecules" link smiley - smiley. It will probably be easier for people to comprehend the concept of colliding molecules without getting into "atoms only" noble gases right away.

Thanks again smiley - cheers,

JAIB


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 8

Ashley


Hey Guys,

I've added that footnote - the more info the better. smiley - ok

Ashley


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 9

Just an innocent bystander

Thanks ! smiley - smiley

What I wanted to say earlier (but forgot) is that I would prefer it to be as "pure argon and neon - as all the noble gases - are not molecular ..." to prevent anyone from getting the idea that this exception is just limited to AR and NE.

smiley - ok

JAIB


Pedantry rules :-P

Post 10

Orcus

smiley - cool

smiley - ta


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more