A Conversation for Socrates
manolan Started conversation Mar 24, 2000
You could add a few lines about his death. You mention his last conversations, but the extraordinary thing to me is to read words spoken by a man who had just taken poison and could feel his body gradually going numb.
BuskingBob Posted Mar 24, 2000
In the words of The Philosophers Song
"Yes, Socrates, himself, is particularly missed;
A lovely little thinker but a bugger when he's pissed!"
Albino Lagomorph Posted Mar 24, 2000
You are right, but then I think everything that Socrates said was amazing to one degree or another. The very fact that he announced his importance to Athens and Greece in the face of the fact that he knew he would suffer death for such "arrogance" is shocking as well.
Once you start adding details of his words, I myself (because I think he is so influential) would not be able to stop
ted.tfl3.113713 Posted Mar 25, 2000
It may also be pointed out that Socrates life could have likely been saved if he had begged forgiveness and renounced his beliefs. He could have also been smuggled out of prison by his friends, but neither of these options were worth the short term gain to Socrates, who accepted death as another part of life, and felt we should have nothing to fear of the unknown if we have lived for good.
Albino Lagomorph Posted Mar 25, 2000
With all these excellent suggestions going about, if I add them in, how do I make sure that you get credit for the information added?
26199 Posted Mar 25, 2000
Just put a note somewhere in the text, or a link to the appropriate person (using in GuideML mode will show the link in the border on the the right but not in the main text) and the sub-editor'll do the rest.
Great article, BTW
Albino Lagomorph Posted Mar 25, 2000
Thanks. I'll try andd o that... if I ever grow to understand what this whole GuideML/HTML suff is. Toasters still confuse me.
Penguin Girl - returned at last Posted Mar 26, 2000
Guide ML is relatively simple. However, if you ever want to use it for other things, I'd learn HTML first.
BuskingBob Posted Mar 27, 2000
You don't need to worry about Guide HTML unless you really want to. As someone else has already said, just put a note in your article; the subs and editors will do the rest.
I enjoyed reading the article.
Albino Lagomorph Posted Mar 27, 2000
Oh, cheers. In that case when (if) I ever have the time to change the entry properly I'll just leave a little note for them then.
Penguin Girl - returned at last Posted Mar 29, 2000
CAN you change entries after they've been approved? I haven't even so much as got anything looked at, so I don't know how that would work.
BuskingBob Posted Mar 30, 2000
Once they've been approved, only the editors can make changes, so if you want to make changes, leave a note for the editor of the article.
Albino Lagomorph Posted Apr 1, 2000
At the very beginning of H2G2, they explained (and it's still in the rules somewhere) that if you contributed to an article you would be put down as an editor. But they didn't explain how to contribute to an article, which was pretty key I would have thought. Never mind eh old sport?
26199 Posted Apr 1, 2000
Contributing to an article is fairly easy... just write the update, submit it, and it'll get added to the article. It's the job of the editors and sub-eds to make sure that if there's already an article on something you've written about, whatever you write gets added to the existing article.
A note somewhere (in the article) pointing in the right direction'd be appreciated, though...
Rufous Posted Apr 2, 2000
And of course the irony of these latter entries is that we'll never know just how much editorial license was employed by the people upon whose works we are reliant for the modern day image of Socrates.
Whilst I agree whole-heartedly that the stories as told by Plato provide the basis for an inspirational and far-sighted figure, (spot on about his death by the way,) shouldn't we be advising a modicum of healthy cynicism?
Otherwise I'd agree with everyone else...Top banana!
Albino Lagomorph Posted Apr 3, 2000
Very true, for all we know Plato could have been writing about a friend named "Wibble," who ate raw fish and sang bawdy songs to the women folk much to their distaste, and decided to give him a better image by portraying him as super-wise.
But either you deny Socrates' existence, accept it, or you highlight the possibility that Plato could be glorifying him in which case you accept that he exists anyway. Drinking in the article with a touch watery scepticism is what (I hope) most people will do anyway.
Cheers for the compliment
Penguin Girl - returned at last Posted Apr 5, 2000
That's always a good idea...
Key: Complain about this post
- 1: manolan (Mar 24, 2000)
- 2: BuskingBob (Mar 24, 2000)
- 3: Albino Lagomorph (Mar 24, 2000)
- 4: ted.tfl3.113713 (Mar 25, 2000)
- 5: Albino Lagomorph (Mar 25, 2000)
- 6: 26199 (Mar 25, 2000)
- 7: Albino Lagomorph (Mar 25, 2000)
- 8: Penguin Girl - returned at last (Mar 26, 2000)
- 9: BuskingBob (Mar 27, 2000)
- 10: Albino Lagomorph (Mar 27, 2000)
- 11: Penguin Girl - returned at last (Mar 29, 2000)
- 12: BuskingBob (Mar 30, 2000)
- 13: Albino Lagomorph (Apr 1, 2000)
- 14: 26199 (Apr 1, 2000)
- 15: Rufous (Apr 2, 2000)
- 16: Albino Lagomorph (Apr 3, 2000)
- 17: Penguin Girl - returned at last (Apr 5, 2000)
- 18: hurley (Jul 18, 2000)
More Conversations for Socrates
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."