This is the Message Centre for Gnomon - time to move on

Apostrophe Theft

Post 1

Gnomon - time to move on

I committed a theft yesterday. I stole an apostrophe from a hardware shop. It was sitting there on a sign made from stick-on letters saying HOSE'S. I checked to see that nobody was looking, then peeled off the apostrophe and removed it from the building without paying.

Luckily, I got away with it.


Apostrophe Theft

Post 2

FordsTowel

A fine proofreader's theft! smiley - ok

If only you could have found a ROSES sign to affix the mark. I think Rose would appreciate it to know where she could find her stuff. smiley - silly

smiley - towel


Apostrophe Theft

Post 3

2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side...

smiley - applause
And, for your next act of gramatical deviance, you will be heading to ASDA and changing the 'less' frto 'fewer' on their stupid checkouts smiley - biggrinsmiley - zen


Apostrophe Theft

Post 4

Baron Grim

Oooh, I'm reporting you for Apostrophe Abuse.

http://www.apostropheabuse.com/smiley - laugh


Apostrophe Theft

Post 5

Galaxy Babe - eclectic editor

If only all typos were so easily fixedsmiley - ok


Apostrophe Theft

Post 6

Gnomon - time to move on

Yes indeed. I saw a sign in a shop window on Monday:

Seating available in-store

What they meant was:

Seating available in store

smiley - sigh


Apostrophe Theft

Post 7

Elentari

Gnomon: hero of the grammar conscious.

Thanks for the link, Count Zero! smiley - laugh


Apostrophe Theft

Post 8

Galaxy Babe - eclectic editor

Have you noticed how badly people react when you *inform* them they've made a spelling/grammar error?

smiley - sadface


Apostrophe Theft

Post 9

Gnomon - time to move on

Lynne Truss's book on the importance of apostrophes is very good:

The Girl's Like Spaghetti


Apostrophe Theft

Post 10

Lanzababy - Guide Editor

In fact when you correct peoples' anything, they are likely to get mad. My daughter got the sack once for changing a menu, translated from Spanish into something stupid like Sir Lion steak into something comprehensible.
smiley - erm
no, it was gilt-head - a fish known locally as Dorada. It was on the specials board and no one was ordering it. When she changed it to Sea Bream, they sold out. She was still sacked. smiley - rolleyes


Apostrophe Theft

Post 11

Baron Grim

Ahem...

http://www.thedoghousediaries.com/?p=302

smiley - laughsmiley - rofl


Apostrophe Theft

Post 12

Baron Grim

The above is for folks familiar with social websites like Reddit and Digg.


Apostrophe Theft

Post 13

Titania (gone for lunch)

*smiley - rofl at the Earl's link*


Apostrophe Theft

Post 14

Recumbentman

Mmm . . . it can be dodgy, correcting people. If they are not selling something for you, you hardly have the right. Think of it as an ethnic situation; everybody's spelling is ethnic to them.

It is fun however correcting a broadcaster. I wrote to Cathal MacCoille (Irish radio journalist) a few months back --

Dear Cathal,

May I suggest that it just doesn't do to amend the grammar of public
figures. After all, where would you begin with someone like George
Bush?

It is worse when your suggestion is a disimprovement, as it was this
morning in the HSE/Ombudsman story.

That arbiter of correctness, the Shorter OED, chooses Goldsmith as the
first authority to quote under the word 'none': 'None of these however
are known to us'.

Fowler (Modern English Usage), under 'none', says: 'It is a mistake to
suppose that the pronoun is singular only and must at all costs be
followed by singular verbs'.

Partridge (Usage and Abusage) devotes over a page to the question,
concluding: 'To say [...] "None of the newspapers has appeared" is no
better than to say "No newspapers has appeared". Indeed, it is worse;
for vulgarity may be forgiven, but pretentiousness carries its own
heavy punishment.'

Yours faithfully


Apostrophe Theft

Post 15

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

I reckon someone's been going round stealing consonants from roadsigns in Wales. Selling them on in Finland.


Apostrophe Theft

Post 16

Recumbentman

(He had read out with disdainful astonishment in his voice a statement by the Ombudsman to the effect that 'None of them were' and then in reported speech with 'was')


Apostrophe Theft

Post 17

Titania (gone for lunch)

Thanks, but the Finns have enough consonants already, as proven of the longest and ancient palindrome in Finnish:

Saippuakauppias


Apostrophe Theft

Post 18

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

Oops. I meant Vowels. They;re stealing *vowels* from Wales and transporting them to Finland.

The Finnish version of 'Countdown':
'I'll have a vowel, please. And another vowel. And another vowel. And another vowel. And another vowel...

The Czech version:
'I'll have a consonant, please. And another consonant. And another consonant. And another consonant...

The Irish version:
'What are these vowels and consonants of which you speak?'


Apostrophe Theft

Post 19

Gnomon - time to move on

>>The Irish version:
'What are these vowels and consonants of which you speak?'

Yes, I've met many Irish people who didn't know that y is a vowel in many words.smiley - winkeye

But W is a vowel in Welsh, and R, L and Z can all be vowels in Eastern European languages.

smiley - smiley


Apostrophe Theft

Post 20

Gnomon - time to move on

"vulgarity may be forgiven, but pretentiousness carries its own
heavy punishment."

I like that.

Kinglsey Amis divided all speakers of English into Berks and W**kers. Berks are ignorant people who don't how to talk properly, and W**kers are pretentious people who think you don't know how to talk properly.


Key: Complain about this post