A Conversation for Ask h2g2
Google - do you trust them?
Bright Blue Shorts Started conversation May 15, 2010
There was a time when Google were just a search engine and a very good one at that.
In recent years they've expanded their activities to Streetview which has had some concerns from privacy people, although I'm not entirely sure whether those are justified.
They've got Google Books which has scanned about 12 million books but there have been lawsuits about copyright.
Now I'm reading that they been 'accidentally' recording information from people's unsecured wi-fi's. Hardly a blunder in my opinion ... http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/8684110.stm
Google - do you trust them?
Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee Posted May 15, 2010
It's been said that Google is a 'geekocracy' - a bunch of techies who don't live in the real world and thus simply don't understand the ethical ramifications of what they do,
Maybe. But it at very least it opens them up to the risk of reverting to capitalist form. 'Don't be evil' is insufficient as an ethical policy.
Google - do you trust them?
Xanatic Posted May 15, 2010
Nope, can´t say I trust them. I read an article on the wi-fi thing in New Scientist recently. However in that one Google seemed to be talking about it as being very deliberate. That it was done to help location searches on google phones, in places where GPS wasn´t accurate enough.
Google - do you trust them?
Hapi - Hippo #5 Posted May 15, 2010
google was never meant to help you people find things on the internet, that's a by-product. Its main reason for being is to make money.
Selling statistical data on internet searches to advertisement agencies is one way to make money. the more accurate and precise that data is, the more it's worth.
Google - do you trust them?
I'm not really here Posted May 15, 2010
"If you are going to broadcast your email on an open wi-fi, don't be surprised if someone picks it up"
I think that's the point. We all need to protect ourselves, in the same way we lock our houses and cars when we go out. Although more information needs to be given at places that let you use their wi-fi, that it might not be secure.
Google - do you trust them?
Bright Blue Shorts Posted May 15, 2010
I think that's precisely NOT the point in terms of what Google were doing. On a general level I agree that you've got to secure your network.
I don't really understand how Google just 'happened' to be collecting all that unsecured information. They must have actively decided to collect it. This was their streetview cars which were supposed to be taking pictures.
To me it's like saying "Oh and by the way as you go down each street check whether the front doors are locked and if they're not, pop in and see whether you can pick up any confidential papers, bank statements, letters, photos ..."
Google - do you trust them?
Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee Posted May 15, 2010
Yeah...but that would be OK, wouldn't it? All they'd do would be to have a quick peek at the letters and papers to see if it gave them any ideas for things we might want to buy.
That wouldn't be so evil, would it?
Google - do you trust them?
Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee Posted May 15, 2010
I remember when wi-fi first appeared. The idea was you'd stick an antenna somewhere and let anyone passing share your bandwidth. We were going to be living in a 'datacloud'.
Google - do you trust them?
I'm not really here Posted May 15, 2010
I tried to argue with BBS, but every argument I came up with meant I actually agreed with that point of view. Can't understand how that happened - that I change my point of view when I try to justify it.
Google - do you trust them?
I'm not really here Posted May 15, 2010
No, it was my flaws! Was going to say it was more like leaving your cash hanging about in the front garden, and some blows into the road, you gotta expect someone's gonna help themselves, right? Then I realised it's still stealing so it didn't help me much.
Key: Complain about this post
Google - do you trust them?
- 1: Bright Blue Shorts (May 15, 2010)
- 2: Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee (May 15, 2010)
- 3: Xanatic (May 15, 2010)
- 4: Hapi - Hippo #5 (May 15, 2010)
- 5: I'm not really here (May 15, 2010)
- 6: Bright Blue Shorts (May 15, 2010)
- 7: Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee (May 15, 2010)
- 8: Not the monkey - Skreeeeeeeeeeeee (May 15, 2010)
- 9: I'm not really here (May 15, 2010)
- 10: Bright Blue Shorts (May 15, 2010)
- 11: I'm not really here (May 15, 2010)
More Conversations for Ask h2g2
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."