A Conversation for The Quite Interesting Society

QI rugby cheats?

Post 1

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

No this is not about the bloodgate scandal, though i do feel that extra penalties on the club are unfair on the fans as well as letting wasps sneek into the henikan.
Without cheating what are the five ways of scoring a try in rugby without going over the try line? (2 points for each plus points for insulting london wasps)


QI rugby cheats?

Post 2

swl

Dunno the answer, but I've often wondered if the London Wasps have a Bee team?


QI rugby cheats?

Post 3

Superfrenchie

... what are the London wasps?

(does this count as an insult?)


I don't know anything about rugby, so... smiley - shrug


QI rugby cheats?

Post 4

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

london wasps are a rugby team that are always in the news, specifically cipriani, if theres any general rugby news then they ask wasps.
And yes two points for not reading about this club smiley - ok


QI rugby cheats?

Post 5

bobstafford

(2 points for each plus points for insulting london wasps) Not allowed under the QI score rules nbbsmiley - smiley


QI rugby cheats?

Post 6

pedro

Penalty try is one.

I suppose grounding the ball after it's been taken over their own line by the defending team could be another.


QI rugby cheats?

Post 7

bobstafford

points for insulting london wasps if last post not clearsmiley - smiley


QI rugby cheats?

Post 8

pedro

Would catching the ball once it's over the line count too?


QI rugby cheats?

Post 9

Orcus

Well the first one is easy, the penalty try. If a player who was (in the opinion of the referee) certain to score a try is fouled and prevented from doing so in the process then a penalty try is awarded with a nice conversion from under the posts to go...


QI rugby cheats?

Post 10

Orcus

simposts.


QI rugby cheats?

Post 11

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

any reason we can't insult wasps? I didnt realise impartiality ruled on the QI sshow, well not if your called Alan Davies.
Pedro gains two points for the penalty try answer and then loses them for his answer, since that would still involve running over the try line.


QI rugby cheats?

Post 12

bobstafford

As far as QI thread is concerned there is no reason (within the bounds of good taste) but you cant give points for the comments...smiley - smiley


QI rugby cheats?

Post 13

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

The QI Scoreboard has the definitions of how to score QI questions. (scroll down to the bottom)

A45429500


QI rugby cheats?

Post 14

bobstafford

Pedro gains two points for the penalty try answer and then loses them for his answer, since that would still involve running over the try line.

You dont take away points just for a wrong answer smiley - bluelight -5 (pre decided by you before you set the question) as you appear not to have set any penalties do nit issue minus points for this question.

Everyone else excuse the use of training wheels new member feeling his way.smiley - smiley


QI rugby cheats?

Post 15

Mu Beta

You can score a try by touching down ON the line or at the base of the posts - neither of which involve crossing the line.

B


QI rugby cheats?

Post 16

bobstafford

Thanks Clive smiley - ok


QI rugby cheats?

Post 17

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

Ah yes, i thought the person jsut chose the answers, will read throught the official rules later.
Yes both of those methods are legitimate answers smiley - ok six points by the apparent rules.


QI rugby cheats?

Post 18

bobstafford

smiley - ok


QI rugby cheats?

Post 19

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

smiley - ok

Just a thought Bob - should the Scores have it's own FAQ, or at the very least be displayed somewhere more prominent than at the bottom of the Scoreboard for precisely this reason for new QI players to consult?


QI rugby cheats?

Post 20

bobstafford

Good idea Clive you have something in mind care to write somethingsmiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post