h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

Entry: Get Your Own H2G2, Without Infringing on Obscure Copyright Laws - A5488103
Author: Gon-So - U1958242

no comment except no comment

from previous PR thread Jimster said :
>>However, it's not a suitable entry for the Edited Guide and so we've >>removed this from Peer Review.

its still not suitable IMHO. I'd advise you to listern to Jimster, he is payed to do this so his word does go.

Have a look at the writing guidelines, and other edited guide entries, see what we want and if you can think of an great guide entry that fits the guide lines write it and send it here. But meanwhile, please go to the Peer Review forum, find this thread and click the remove button next to it.

ta

tjm

Just out of interest, why have you re-sumitted this for inclusion in the Edited Guide when one of the Editors has taken it out of Peer Review?

If you sent an article to a magazine for inclusion and they very politely sent it back for being unsuitable, would you waste the postage and their time in getting it sent off to them again?

Just a thought.

It's not like we're asking you to get rid of your entry. It just doesn't belong in Peer Review, which is only for entries that follow the <./>writing-guidelines</.>. h2g2 does have rules and regulations, and all we ask is that you adhere to them to keep the site running smoothly.