A Conversation for The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Peer Review: A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 1

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

Entry: The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept - A989922
Author: Whoami? © - U177581

Let's see how this one gets on - it could almost be shortened for BoTF, too...

Whoami? smiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 2

Number Six

Good stuff. They're building a high-speed overground long-distance maglev link between two major cities in China. I forget which ones, though.

Isn't it spelt 'Salzburg'?


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 3

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

Sure is - thanks for that. I may have been looking at the Swissmetro website in the origina; French and that got me thinking in French. smiley - doh

Salzbourg -> Salzburg done.

Whoami? smiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 4

Rho

I'd never heard of this before - if only they had trains like that here! smiley - winkeye

My only suggestion would be to link to A305399, which describes Magnetic Levitation in a little more detail. smiley - smiley

RhoMuNuQ


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 5

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

I suppose, although it's buried in loads of other stuff and is quite daunting. What does everyone else think? smiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 6

Oberon2001 (Scout)

Definitely need a link (or a longer explanation) on Maglev and in the absence of a proper entry on it I suppose that'll have to do (maybe add a footnote that A305399 goes into slightly more detail on Maglev)... or you could always find an external link on it....
Maglev sites -
http://www.fra.dot.gov/rdv/hsgt/maglev.htm (commercial and US-centric)
http://www.railserve.com/maglev.html (reccommended, goes into a lot of depth)
http://www.amasci.com/maglev/magschem.html (sciency, maybe not good for the lay reader)

A point against Maglev trains -> should they crash at top speed (heaven forbid) passengers will disintergrate on impact (something to do with the high speeds apparently)

Nice entry and like you said, fiddle around with it and it could go into the BotF as well. smiley - biggrin
Oberon2001


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 7

Mammuthus Primigenius

Good entry.

You are a bit unkind to maglev technology. It's certaintly worth mentioning some other projects, as well as the Brimingham airport train.

Another link to look at: http://www.transrapid.de.

MP


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 8

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

OK. I'll give it some thought and see what I can manage...

Whoami? smiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 9

Number Six

I remember that the same article that mentioned the Chinese project said that most of the technological knowhow being used was German... Britain led the world in maglev technology in thr 80s, but soon got overtaken smiley - sadface


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 10

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

Sure did - the Chinese project site keeps reverting to German and is done with German expertise.

Whoami? smiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 11

Number Six

You're missing the full stop from the end of your maglev sentence, by the way...

I'm too lazy to bother right now (touch of the flu) but have you had a hunt for h2g2 links for any of the cities involved?


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 12

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

Not yet. Will do, I'll take a peek tomorrow afternoon! smiley - smileysmiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 13

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

I'll fix this this afternoon, promise! smiley - smileysmiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 14

Back_Ache

I like this artical, I agree with the others however that a seperate artical for you to link to about maglev is needed.

The mention of the channel tunnel assumes people know what it is a little footnote and a link to the edited artical on the the subject should fix that (A134740)

In general a good artical thats makes me hungry to find out more (which is a very good thing)


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 15

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

That's good to know - thanks for the feedback! smiley - smileysmiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 16

Rho

*bump*

These are all the relevant links that I could find:
- A305399, Maglev
- A134740, Channel Tunnel
- A596054, Lucerne
- A306947, St Gallen
- A190144, Vienna

I couldn't find relevant links for:
- Switzerland
- Lyons
- Geneva
- Lausanne
- Bern
- Zurich
- Munich
- Salzburg
- Linz
- Edinburgh
- London

Additionally:
- Birmingham Internation Airport > Birmingham International Airport
- every 4 minutes > every four minutes

smiley - smiley
RhoMuNuQ


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 17

Number Six

Edinburgh's A973686. Been recommended but not edited yet, but by the time this makes it, it should be in.

A742772 could be worth it, it's on Expat Bars in Lyon, so if you want a link to Lyon that could be it...

smiley - mod


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 18

Rho

Good point - I only searched for Edited Entries but should have included Recommended Entries. smiley - smiley

RhoMuNuQ


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 19

Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation

OK. Thanks for those. I'll have a bash at getting this finished tomorrow. smiley - smileysmiley - cake


A989922 - The Swissmetro/Eurometro Concept

Post 20

Rho

Brilliant smiley - smiley

RhoMuNuQ


Key: Complain about this post