A Conversation for PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
The H2G2 Editors Started conversation Aug 19, 2003
Entry: PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK - A989544
Author: AnGeLiCwItCh.*n€€d oF h€lP - U218079
We took this out of PR. However, it appears to be part of 2 more sections which may be combined. The author has reappeared and has received advice from Grey Desk on Part 3 of the entry here: "What you need to put in is detail about the places you've listed. All you have at the moment is just a list.
"As I mentioned in the Peer Review thread about Part 2 of your Leeds entry, try taking a look at the entry that is in the Edited Guide all about Bradford - A617401 - this is the kind of thing that the editors are looking for from a guide entry."
We've put this back into PR and we'll wait a while to see how it all works out. 
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
AngelicWitch (ACE) Posted Aug 19, 2003
I dont understand 
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
J Posted Aug 19, 2003
I think the editors made a mistake in taking your entry out and wanted to undo that. But then they took it out again...
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive Posted Aug 19, 2003
Well, I'm confused. What about everyone else?
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
GreyDesk Posted Aug 19, 2003
It looks like they've not properly reinstated the entry back into Peer Review.
Given that the conversation such as it is, is happening on the other Peer Review thread for this entry, I would suggest reinstating that thread and not this one as the PR thread. Did that make any sense 
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive Posted Aug 19, 2003
I don't think they can reinstate a particular thread but I agree with you that the conversation should continue in the original Peer Review thread but with the article not actually *in* Peer Review until it complies better with the Guidelines. At that point AngelicWitch can put the article back into Peer Review creating a third PR thread.
Amy 
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
GreyDesk Posted Aug 19, 2003
That strikes me as a good idea 
The next post I make here in a moment or two will be an attempt to shut off this thread and redirect traffic to the other thread.
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive Posted Aug 19, 2003
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK - please don't post here
GreyDesk Posted Aug 19, 2003
*** PLEASE DON'T POST HERE *** The thread that is in use for comments about "Places to Visit in Leeds" is here - http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/F117243?thread=291341
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review: A989544 - PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
- 1: The H2G2 Editors (Aug 19, 2003)
- 2: J (Aug 19, 2003)
- 3: AngelicWitch (ACE) (Aug 19, 2003)
- 4: J (Aug 19, 2003)
- 5: Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive (Aug 19, 2003)
- 6: GreyDesk (Aug 19, 2003)
- 7: Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive (Aug 19, 2003)
- 8: GreyDesk (Aug 19, 2003)
- 9: Amy the Ant - High Manzanilla of the Church of the Stuffed Olive (Aug 19, 2003)
- 10: GreyDesk (Aug 19, 2003)
More Conversations for PLACES TO VISIT, LEEDS UK
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."