A Conversation for

All this happens?

Post 41

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

it is excellent! in re reading it just now


All this happens?

Post 42

*!TaNyA!*ThE aTtEnTioN SeEkinG brAt Is BacK^!

i think luna lovegood liked ron!?! and ive re read the book and i stil cant work out that veil?!?
lilly and james were on the order-maybe thats what they ment by "occupation"?!?
oh and there has to be something bout nevill and harry in the next book, b'cuz both nevill and harrys parents excaped voldemort 3 times!! maybe voldemort got it wrong and nevill is the on who will distroy him!?! lol!!
oh and i think hary might die in the last book aswell......anyone else think so?!?!


All this happens?

Post 43

Eccentra

Due to some major mailing confusion on my part, I still don't have my book. Basically I had my book sent to my fiancé's apartment and he stopped his mail because he went out of town for a couple of weeks. Unfortunately I inadvertantly found out who died and I'm really not happy about finding out and about who it is. So...I'm looking forward to actually getting to read it.


All this happens?

Post 44

Anarane


We do find out about Lily and James's occupations, The were In the Order Of The Phoenix!


All this happens?

Post 45

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

but surely they had jobs too?


All this happens?

Post 46

DJR

yeh Dumbledore, McGonagall, Hagrid, Snape etc. are all in the Order, but they're occupations are TEACHERS. Being in the Order isn't an occupation.


All this happens?

Post 47

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

im having fun inagining the order as a hobby. surely james would have played quidditch?


All this happens?

Post 48

Anarane

You're right, they probably have jobs too so maybe we will find out in books 6 or 7.
When I wrote that article, they were NOT my ideas, I got them from the ideas of others on the internet, from the official HP site, BBC Newsround or Newspapers ect. I didnt say that these things would definately happen, not intentionally at least.

Anyway, What were your views on the book and what were your thoughts on the character who died? I don't know why but I wasn't as upset when the person died in book 5 as I was when Cedric died in book 4. And I think thats odd considering I liked the person who dies in book 5 a lot more. They were one of my faves.

Did anyone else keep feeling frustrated when Harry kept getting angry?


All this happens?

Post 49

DJR

i got p*ssed off with harry cos he was getting p*ssed off over the smallest thing - it was gd when he felt guilty afterwards.

i bet he isn't dead - there's something about the fact that no1 has seen his dead body that just suggests to me that there's some twist...


All this happens?

Post 50

Anarane



Good point, I think what Luna Lovegood had something to do with it. She said that he wasnt really gone or something like that but i still dont fully understand the "veil" part so im going to read that bit again. Another thing Im confused with is how did he actually die? Was he pushed or something?

I think Fred and George brought great humour to the book which was what was needed with Harrys outbursts of anger and frustration.


All this happens?

Post 51

*!TaNyA!*ThE aTtEnTioN SeEkinG brAt Is BacK^!

he got hit by a curse and then he fell in2 the veil!


All this happens?

Post 52

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

i know what you mean. he is my favourite character, but cedric's death was sadder, and i had to re read it to realise what actually happened in this book.
i dont think this one is as good as goblet. but what i love about this one it that up til now we've been given characters to hate from a distance, lockheart is smug and annoying, voldemort we are told to hate, but you can really come to LOATHE umbridge. she just get so much on my nerves. rowling has an impressive talent.


All this happens?

Post 53

Anarane


Lockhart is smug but i cant help liking him, especially in this book because he's so hopeless and like a child's mind when he boasts of learning up joined up handwriting! I think because of this he's more cute than annoying!
We love Fred and George even more because of what they do to Umbridge and I disliked Harry when he kept getting angry at the smallest thing.


All this happens?

Post 54

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

how annoying was harry in this? "look! my chair is a millkimeter out of place! i must throuw a tantrum!"
fred and george are brilliant!


All this happens?

Post 55

Anarane

yeah i know! I know he's been through a lot but he could at least stop taking his anger out on ron and hermione who have stood by him for 4/5 years! harry should remember he has no other friends outside hogwarts!
whos your fave character? Snape rocks!


All this happens?

Post 56

Johanna the Psychotic Bananna - - I'm back!!! I missed you, H2G2

for ages it was sirius but he got on my nerves a bit in this book. im beginning to like snape a bit more now, but i still dont know.

i relly like luna,and ginny,theyre both great


All this happens?

Post 57

Anarane


I love Hermione's SPEW lol


All this happens?

Post 58

DJR

hmm, if i knew someone as annoying as her then i'd burn all those crappy hats. nice one dobby.


All this happens?

Post 59

Anarane

I think I liked Ron's reactions to it more. Dobby rules!


All this happens?

Post 60

911 Emergency Response

listen up,

this is about how sirius died.

As neasrly headless nick explains, when wizaeds and witches die thery can either choose to come back as a ghost and hang around for eternity (even if all the people in the earth died they would still have to stay there for ever) or they can choose to "pass on" into the unknown. No-one knows what this other choice is and nearly headless nick sadly explains that he does not know because he didn't choose it. The veiled arch in the ministry of magic was a doorway through to the mysterious second choice. That is wherever people go when they die can be reached through the veil. This explains the whispering on the other side (all the dead people). It only works one way so that whie anyone can walk though and visit the dead, dead people cannot come out. If you walked through it however, you would die because only dead people can be on the other side. Sirius did not die because of a deadly curse, it was only a stunning spell or something that pushed sirius over (through the veil, killing him). That is why he died. I would like to point out that he would not have felt himself die because he was had not been killed or wounded, his life had just been taken away (similar to the avada kedavra curse). If you were to walk through the veil, this is what you would experience. You would go through the veil and see the dead people. You would not notice any change to yourself and woud feel exactly the same. You would be dead though. When you tried to return you would not be able to go back through as the veiled arch is only one way. Sirius would have been hit by a curse, fallen on his back, gotten up to rejoin the fight only to find that he could not go back because he was dead. i imagine he would be quite upset which is why i feel so sorry for his character, being unable to help all of a sudden.


Key: Complain about this post