A Conversation for The Nearly but Not Quite 'Official' Peer Review Discussion Forum

Flea Market

Post 1

Mina

I've been through PR rescuing some good content (I hope!) and putting it into PR, and I've got a couple I'm not sure about.

I don't know anything about the subjects, and the PR threads do see, happy with the entries, but don't actually say if they are close enough to be ready to be put through by someone else.

Would some other Researchers take a look and see if they think the entries can be saved without having an expert do it? I'm happy to put the time in, but no point rescuing something only to find it's beyond me and wasting everyone's time.

The entries are:

A2169191 - How to Play Texas 42
A2697474 - Honda's VTEC engines

I'll carry on looking, and will post here again if there are any others I'm not sure about.

smiley - ta


Flea Market

Post 2

Mina

A1155728 - How to smell a Ponderosa Pine


Flea Market

Post 3

Rod

Eco Worrier: I can only give support in a negative way - like you, no expertise.

- Honda's VTEC Engine: It all sounds reasonable - but can't comment technically.

- Ponderosa Pine: I've never knowingly under-stood one, or even seen one.

- Texas 42: All my enemies died young and I no longer have enough friends.

To my inexperienced eye, they all look worthwhile - good luck with them.


Flea Market

Post 4

Rod

Oh, one thing.

I've read of various forest plants that require brush-fires, but have understood that it was their seeds that need the heat in order to become viable...?


Flea Market

Post 5

Fizzymouse- no place like home



....but the Giant Redwood needs the space.smiley - ok


smiley - mouse


Flea Market

Post 6

BMT

The Honda VTEC article wouldn't take much to complete. It needs a few tweaks in terms phrases/words used to describe the process's but is otherwise, good, factual and not far off done.




{Speaking as a Vehicle diagnostics Technician for over 25 years smiley - smiley }


smiley - cat


Flea Market

Post 7

Galaxy Babe - eclectic editor

I was just going to say ST would be your man for the Honda thingsmiley - silly

A great idea, I've just completed an update that's been bugging me for a while, and submitted one FM rescue that was sitting on my PS. I'll have a look for more nuggets which won't need much polishingsmiley - run


Flea Market

Post 8

Mina

Feel free to help yourself to one of these if you want them. I've got nine in PR at the moment - although it's possible some of those will come out again - so these would have to wait anyway.


Flea Market

Post 9

Mina

Meant to say thanks for the support on these!

If anyone else wants to take them on, then feel free.


Flea Market

Post 10

Galaxy Babe - eclectic editor

None of yours thankssmiley - okI've got my hands full at the minute smiley - sadface


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more