A Conversation for The strange world of the pencil case

Peer Review: A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 1

Alpha5

Entry: The strange world of the pencil case - A849512
Author: Alpha5 - U205983

A new and refreshing insite into the curious world of an oject taken for granted


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 2

Z

Welcome to H2G2 this is a great start, the content fits all the writing guidlines, infromative, factual, real life, and there's no current article on pencils.

Just a couple of small points.

There's a tiny bit of first person at the end, "I hope this has given you an insite.." which according to writing guidelines shouldn't be in there. Also have you considered putting it into guide ML. Then you could mkae all your headers proper headers rather than just capitals.

If you're interested then have a read of the guide ML clinic at A187229
and you might want to link to a guide entry on pencils at A526178.

Keep at it and do make these changes then I'm sure this will soon be edited guide material!


Well Done smiley - bubbly
smiley - magic
Z


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 3

Alpha5

I cant get guide ML to work. Im trying to get the line to break but it says 'bad line closure line expectency NULL


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 4

Z

I think that means that you've put an extra opening tag when you don't need it. If you're using the tag then you don't need an opening tag at all it's a stand alone tag. So just insert when you want the line to break!


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 5

Alpha5

thanks, ive made some changes, you might want to see them...smiley - smiley


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 6

King Cthulhu of Balwyniti

Using tags around the text will make it look better, separate the text from the headers smiley - ok


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 7

Z

Well done this is a great improvement! King Cthulhu of Balwyniti's sugestion of putting and around the paragraphs is a good one.

Also you can actually link to another entry it's self. The way I'd do it is one of the times you've writen pencil to make it into hyperlink. You can do this by typing pencils.

Another thing that would really improve the appearance of it is running it through a spell checker.This takes around 30 Seconds.
I do it by

Copying the contents of the edit entry box into a word document.

Correcting all the spelling mistakes in the text it's self (it will also think that some of the tags are spelling mistakes, leave that).

Copying it from the word document to a notepad one.
Then from notepad to the edit entry box again.

Done.

smiley - magic





A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 8

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

What about wooden pencil cases? Similar to the metal ones you explained, but with a top which either slides out lengthways, or swivels. Those were the Rolls Royce of pencil cases when I was at school. They were about the same size as the metal cases you describe, and they were compartmented. The creme de la creme wooden pencil cases had a top tray which lifted out to reveal another compartment underneath. Usually made of beech as I recall.


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 9

U195780

Really strange yet interesting ! smiley - smiley


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 10

egon

"Those were the Rolls Royce of pencil cases when I was at school. £

Er, which century were you at school exactly Gosho?


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 11

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

I was at school for most of the 1960s and a little bit of the 70s. So that would be last century.


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 12

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

And if Z tells you to run it by a spell checker, you can tell it really needs it (smiley - sorry, Z - couldn't resistsmiley - kiss)!

A spell checker wouldn't find this one, though:

wears > wares

as both are proper spellings.

Not looked thoroughly, so there may be other things to say - and as has been said earlier - it looks a good start!smiley - ok

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 13

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

- smiley - yikes Better start spell checking myself. smiley - silly

I agree with Gosho on the Rolls Royce pencil cases, BTW.

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 14

Z

No offense taken ZSF! I almost put that in my reccomendation myself.


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 15

Terran

Yep, good idea. Pencil Cases are definately weird smiley - weird. Though they're not as weird as Bookcases (A810055).
Theres a few seplling mistakes but other than that it looks like you've got a good article coming along smiley - ok

Terran smiley - earth


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 16

Terran

smiley - blush, spelling mistakes (I can talk!)


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 17

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

The bag type pencil cases are *very* strange, because no matter how much stuff you put in them, they're never quite full, and when you go to look for something you know you put in there, you can't find it. Pencil cases are portals to alternative dimensions and universes.


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 18

Terran

Are you sure your not talking about TARDIS'?


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 19

Alpha5

Ive made some spelling corrections, look at it now


A849512 - The strange world of the pencil case

Post 20

Z

Even though the text hasn't changed much it look so much better then when you first entered it, well done for sticking at it.

smiley - magic
Z


Key: Complain about this post