A Conversation for "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 21

Martin Harper

I've had an entry with 'hir' in picked before now, so that sets a precedent. And the sub-ed rewrote it then, and whoever gets it to sub will probably rewrite it this time too, assuming sie agrees with the last sub's decision.

Mountain, meet molehill.
-Xanthia


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 22

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

Can't say I'd act any differently in the sub's position.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 23

Hoovooloo

I wouldn't say "the glass is half empty".

I wouldn't say "the glass if half full".

I might say "the glass contains 284ml". If it's a pint pot.

Engineers, eh?

Like the entry. Daft pronouns and all.

H.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 24

Martin Harper

What a lovely comment, Hoovooloo. Daft author and all. smiley - smiley

-MyRedDice


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 25

Martin Harper

Quotes and a link added. Written By list updated. Go wild...
-myre


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 26

Dr Hell

Hello,

...this is not the usual standard Entry for the Edited Guide, but what the hey. I guess the Editor of THHGTTG did a good job.

PLUS:

According to Kurt Gödel, there is no way to decide whether the glass is half-full or half empty

Heisenberg would say that it's impossible to determine the volume with infinite precision, so in the end it's uncertain.

Another thought: The glass is always full, full with atoms.

Plus: What is the *fundamental character* of empty? Can something be totally empty? Vacuum? How much vacuum did you put in there?

And: It also depends what it is that's in there. Socrates would have preferred a half-filled cup...

Well, well, well...

What the...

HELL


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 27

Martin Harper

I've put in a footnote about the glass not containing poison (cv Socrates). I think I'll avoid talk of the fundamental character of emptiness, though... smiley - yikes

How goes it?
-Martin


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 28

spook

solutions to a half empty/full glass:

if u considor it to be half empty, drink what's left and make it completely empty.

if u considor it to be half full, pour the contents into a smaller glass so that u have a full glass, or add more of the contents to the present glass.

i don't think there is anything good or bad about how people biew the glass, but it is simply the direction in which they see the glass taking - either becoming empty or becoming full.

nice entry btw smiley - smiley

spook


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 29

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

In a noble act of self-sacrifice, I'm going to remove my name from this article so I can recommend it as a Scout. That way, it stops cluttering up my Unedited Articles list.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 30

spook

i think u can recommend articles if u r a contributor, just not if u r the editor. a while back i recommended an entry i was a contributor off. i noticed that most scouts were contributors to that entry which was probably why it hadn't already been recommended.

spook


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 31

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

Ah fine, but I don't have a monthly quota for written articles, but I DO have one for recommendations. So it's in my interest to make sure that this gets recommended whatever way. Which I have done.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 32

Martin Harper

Whatever.

Shall I re-add you to the credits, Felonious?


Congratulations - Your Entry has been Picked for the Edited Guide!

Post 33

h2g2 auto-messages

Your Guide Entry has just been picked from Peer Review by one of our Scouts, and is now heading off into the Editorial Process, which ends with publication in the Edited Guide. We've therefore moved this Review Conversation out of Peer Review and to the entry itself.

If you'd like to know what happens now, check out the page on 'What Happens after your Entry has been Recommended?' at EditedGuide-Process. We hope this explains everything.

Thanks for contributing to the Edited Guide!


Splendid

Post 34

Martin Harper

Graceful thanks to those who helped.
Graceless Yanks to those who didn't help.
And we leave you with news that in Syria, Yasser Arafat has been happilly re-united with his favourite childhood pet.

Good night!


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 35

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

If you can, it would be appreciated.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 36

Martin Harper

up to sub-ed now.

I can't actually remember what I gave you credit for, anyway. It can't just have been the pessimist's glass link, can it? smiley - erm


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 37

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

Probably. Well, what the hell, the more the merrier.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 38

Martin Harper

A830387 is the sub-ed's version.


A795648 - "The glass is half full" - Good or bad?

Post 39

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

Doesn't matter: the main thing is that it's been accepted.


Key: Complain about this post