A Conversation for The h2g2 Doctor Who Group

Time Crash

Post 1

Mister Matty

No opinions on the CID mini-episode, then?


Time Crash

Post 2

Mister Matty

CIN, even

*cough* editfunction *cough*


Time Crash

Post 3

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

It was lovely.

"You were /my/ Doctor"

I got a bit mushy a that point.


Time Crash

Post 4

Mister Matty

I enjoyed it too. It was shamelessly fanboyish in a way I worry may have alienated a lot of newer fans but it was enjoyable enough and I liked how they managed to fill a few gaps (why the Fifth Doctor looked older, why the TARDIS interior changes, why Titanic managed to breach the TARDIS). Interesting that it was clearly part of official continuity and yet "fits in" between two points in an existing episode rather than at the end of one (as happened in the 2005 CIN mini-episode). I wonder if they'll insert it (optionally or otherwise) in future DVD releases of "Last Of The Timelords".


Time Crash

Post 5

Mister Matty

Another thing I read somewhere that plug a bit of a plot hole: it explains why the Doctor is a) scared and b) so convinced it can only be the Master when Martha tells him another Time Lord has survived in "Utopia".


Time Crash

Post 6

van-smeiter

Eh? This happened after Utopia.


Time Crash

Post 7

Terran

"Eh? This happened after Utopia."

And yet simultaneously before Utopia... wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey... smiley - weird


Time Crash

Post 8

Mister Matty

Yes, the Doctor *remembered* being warned of the Master's return when he was the fifth Doctor and this would explain his instant fear when Martha tells him she might have found another timelord...


Time Crash

Post 9

Jozcoz

he must have also *remembered* that he didn't have that rubbish beardsmiley - tongueout


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more