A Conversation for Why the Earth has Seasons

A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 1

Bright Blue Shorts

A futile attempt to explaining something taught to 10 years old. All comments welcome smiley - smiley

http://www.h2g2.com/A506521


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 2

Inkwash

Brilliant! Let's get some scouts in here!


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 3

Cloviscat

This is a nice entry, and I like the fact it links so strongly to an easy demopnstartion. I wonder if there are any edited entries out there on a (perhaps more theoretical) associated subject, to which you could provide links?


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 4

shrinkwrapped

This is nice - the practical demonstration reminds me of Junior school!


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 5

Bright Blue Shorts

Thank-you.

I will be adding some links - good suggestion. I found entries on the Sun & Earth, also one on the North Pole, Alaska which I think is a bit of a red herring. Then I found one on the Precession of the Earth .... and discovered this part bit is a bit inaccurate smiley - sadface I'll have to do a bit of correcting.


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 6

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

*In terms of the seasons this has no effect. In fact about the only effects of it are that Christmas day (December 25th) no longer falls on mid-Winter's day as it did when it was first initiated*

In the Southern hemisphere Christmas Day has never fallen on mid-Winter's day - it is the middle of summer. This was accentuated a couple of hundred years ago when Pope Gregory added 11 days to the Julian calander.

Us Southerners look forward to the first Southern Hemisphere Pope adjusting all religious festivals to take account of the fact that the Earth rotates from South to North, - remember the millennium fireworks displays - a fact unknown by the early Christian novelists and northern pagans.


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 7

Bright Blue Shorts

Ahhh yes wonder if any of you Southerners would pick me up on the Christmas day / mid-winter's day thing. I wrote it that way because I didn't reckon they'd have any knowledge of the Southern hemisphere when they initiated Christmas. Anyone know?

Just remembered I found at the June 21 & Dec 21 are the Summer & Winter Solstice, more correct name.

How does the Earth rotate South to North? Rotation is either clockwise or anticlockwise (counterclockwise if you like). Isn't it?


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 8

Lear (the Unready)

Agreed. A very clear explanation of something I never managed to learn at school. Worth a bookmark. smiley - smiley


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 9

Lear (the Unready)

Arrgh. I was agreeing with post No.4, to save any confusion.


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 10

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

As seen from the North Pole, which direction does the Earth rotate? Counter-clockwise.

The first humans to realise our planet was spherical were early native Australians, probably when harvesting their crops in March - Autumn (Fall)


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 11

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

The last humans to realise the planet rotated were the American advertising people who invented Father Christmas, complete with heavy weather gear, in the 1930s.


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 12

Salamander the Mugwump

Good entry. Nicely explained. Well done.


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 13

Bright Blue Shorts

Thanks everybody for your comments.

I have just revised the entry as follows:
- added a few link to other guide entries
- changed a bit of the terminology, corrected inaccuracies
- added a note to say that seasons in Southern hemisphere are wrong way round smiley - winkeye
- got rid of some typos, grammos & spellos. I think, however, some still exist so if you see any point them out please.

Confession time - I haven't actually tried out the practicals so I don't truly know they work. However in minds eye they do and the theory behind is right. Anyone tried them yet?


THREAD CLOSED

Post 14

shrinkwrapped

Well, I certainly hope those practical demonstrations work, as this article has been picked for submission to the Editing process! Woo! Please wait nicely while the Sub Eds 'do their business', and also while they edit your entry. You'll get a mail telling you when it's been added to The Guide, you lucky guy. smiley - biggrin


THREAD CLOSED

Post 15

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

I look forward to the related yarn - "Enjoying A Summer's Day On The Moon"


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 16

Ausnahmsweise, wie üblich (Consistently inconsistent)

Hi,
Pope Gregory r e m o v e d 10 days. But the by time the UK got around to adjusting, a couple of hundred years later, 11 were needed. Sept. 1752 went 1,2,14,15,16.


There's a lady posting here whose nick name is "I want my 11 days back".


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 17

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

10+2=12


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 18

Ausnahmsweise, wie üblich (Consistently inconsistent)

Hi,
Pope Gregory r e m o v e d 10 days. But the by time the UK got around to adjusting, a couple of hundred years later, 11 were needed. Sept. 1752 went 1,2,14,15,16.


There's a lady posting here whose nick name is "I want my 11 days back".


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 19

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

2+10=12


A506521 - Why the Earth has Seasons

Post 20

Ausnahmsweise, wie üblich (Consistently inconsistent)

????? I know 10+2=12.
What's the significance?

Gregory (or at least his mathematician) came up with approx. 10 (debated between 9,10 and 11). Decided to go with 10. He decided that the next day after Oct. 4, 1582, should be called Oct. 15.

Are you suggesting that the delta after ca. 200 years should only have been 2 days (10+2=12)?


Key: Complain about this post