A Conversation for Herbs in History

Peer Review: A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 1

frenchbean

Entry: A History of Herb Cultivation - A3377928
Author: Frenchbean <6 stars> Trying to find my rhythm again - U236943

Hello Peerers smiley - smiley

This started off as an entry about Physic Gardens, which kind of changed emphasis as I wrote.

Comments and peering welcomed as always smiley - ok

Six smiley - star Fb


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 2

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

"essential"
Hmmm....

"Basic or indispensable; necessary"
"Biochemistry. Being a substance that is required for normal functioning but cannot be synthesized by the body and therefore must be included in the diet: essential amino acids."

Perhaps 'essential' is not quite right word? smiley - smiley


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 3

frenchbean

Gosho smiley - smiley
Good point. Word changed to 'important'.
smiley - ok


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 4

Gnomon - time to move on

I don't feel like reading through this at the moment, Frenchbean, but one word jumped out at me: enahnce.


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 5

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

This looks like a good 'un. I'm wondering if it might be worth including a bit about the Doctrine of Signatures: http://www.holysmoke.org/wb/wb0081.htm ?


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 6

frenchbean

Typo sorted, Gnomon smiley - ok

I never heard of the Doctrine, Felonious smiley - erm I'll read it later and perhaps add something about it smiley - smiley

I am not at all sure that the title is right smiley - erm Should it be 'History of Herb Usage'? It's not really about cultivation smiley - doh


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 7

frenchbean

A few changes made, which probably nobody will notice, since you've not read it yet smiley - dohsmiley - laugh


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

Why not just 'Herbs in History' ?

all sorts fo herbs --> all sorts of herbs

Would it be worth adding footnotes to explain the quotations? For example, Matrix = Uterus


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 9

frenchbean

Title changed smiley - ok I think that's better. Thanks Gn

Typo fixed.

I'd thought about footnotes for the quotes, but I kind of like the mystery of the words smiley - erm What does anybody else think? I'll certainly add some if folk reckon it'll help the entry smiley - smiley


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 10

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

When I first read Matrix, I had this vision of Agent Smith being brought down by elderflowers. So I agree it would be a good idea to include the footnotes.


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 11

frenchbean

Okay... footnotes will be added later on today smiley - smiley


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 12

Mina

Lovely entry. A nice link jumped out at me though:

In ancient Athens, violets were worn in wreaths to ward off drunkenness. At public baths Athenians were rubbed with herbs and herb oils (A636914) to enhance their strength and courage.


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 13

Mina

Oh, and this might be a nice entry to reference - Harvesting and Preserving Herbs A2061703


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 14

frenchbean

Thank you Mina smiley - smiley I'll add those later on too smiley - ok


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 15

Mina

Just thought I'd do some self-promotion!


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 16

frenchbean

It worked, Mina smiley - laugh

Amendments made smiley - ok


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 17

frenchbean

Felonious smiley - smiley

Thank you for the link to the Doctrine of Signatures. I had heard of it before, but didn't know it was an actual philosophy/doctrine, with a name smiley - wow I've added a paragraph about it smiley - ok

Six smiley - star Fb


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 18

frenchbean

smiley - whistle

Okay... who hasn't picked on this one yet? No more pedants out there to hassle me? I don't believe it smiley - tongueout

smiley - somersault


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 19

Gnomon - time to move on

Hmm, I must get around to reading this.


A3377928 - A History of Herb Cultivation

Post 20

frenchbean

smiley - whistle


Key: Complain about this post