A Conversation for Band Aid 20

Peer Review: A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 1

AlexAshman

Entry: Band Aid 20 - A3371717
Author: AlexAshman - Do they know it's Christmas? - U566116

The single came out on Monday, and so I've written a guide entry to augment the original Band Aid entry which claims the story ended in 1989 with Band Aid II.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 2

Mort - a middle aged Girl Interrupted

good idea!

Unfortunately there is probably with <./>copyright</.> as regards the lyrics. So you will have to remove them.

Sorry!


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 3

AlexAshman


Righto. Lyrics removed.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 4

Gnomon - time to move on

I'm not sure that this should go in as a separate entry.smiley - erm Would it not be better to add this information to the end of the original entry? That could be done in the Update Forum.

every christmas --> every Christmas


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 5

Smij - Formerly Jimster

I'm sure we could do with a separate entry and link the two.

Although as we've been saying ever since we saw the final line-up, it's not Band Aid ithout Bananarama! smiley - winkeye

Can you take a look at your dates? The <./>writing-guidelines</.> should help you out with the formatting there.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 6

Gnomon - time to move on

Jimster, you'll probably have to do a quick bit of editing of the original when this one is published, in that case.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 7

Gnomon - time to move on

It's a well-written entry, Alex.

You mention the rap bit twice, once in the main text and once as a footnote. You only need one of these.

Put a space after the name Hawkins.

Convert any full dates to h2g2 format, for example 25 November, 2004.

the proceeds ... was used
-- that should be "were used".

smiley - smiley


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 8

AlexAshman


Ok, thanks everyone.smiley - biggrin

I've sorted out all the things you've mentioned, but I'm wondering whether I should change the first subheader to avoid repetition...smiley - erm

smiley - cheers


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 9

Gnomon - time to move on

Yes, you should change it to "Twenty Years On" and make it a header.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 10

AlexAshman


Sounds like a good idea... ok, done it smiley - smiley


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 11

Mort - a middle aged Girl Interrupted

Glad you didn't mind taking out the lyrics - sorry about that.

I would suggest using a Header for Furthur Information as it is a seperate section from the previous paragraph.

I am a big fan of bulleted lists. If you used


text with link here
blah blah blah
etc...
</UL

Then it will space out the links bullet pointed more centrally on the page and finish off the article nicely smiley - ok


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 12

AlexAshman


That's ok smiley - biggrin

I've made the changes you suggested smiley - cheers


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 13

AlexAshman

smiley - whistle


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 14

Mol - on the new tablet

This looks good, let's keep bouncing it up the list smiley - winkeye

Mol


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 15

AlexAshman


Sorry, I was rather hoping that I could get it through before Christmas... smiley - smiley


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 16

Gnomon - time to move on

By the rules, it can't be picked until it's been in Peer Review a week.


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 17

AlexAshman


I didn't know that...


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 18

AlexAshman


So - does that give it a chance of making it in time? smiley - smiley


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 19

Mol - on the new tablet

It has been known - How to Build a Snowman went from PR to front page in a matter of days when the circumstances were right, although I can't remember how long it had been hanging around PR before that. It does depend on a scout recommending it at exactly the right time. Can't help you there myself, I only deal in typos.

Mol


A3371717 - Band Aid 20

Post 20

Z

Why not drop a note to the Scouts Yahoo group and see if a nice sloping person will be able to help you out?

(obviously you'd have to be a Scout to do this..)


Key: Complain about this post