A Conversation for Zelda - Hebrew Poet

Peer Review: A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 1

Yael Smith

Entry: Zelda- Hebrew Poet - A21423872
Author: Elly (oh, alright, I'll work!) - U166393

I'm submitting A21423872 - 'Zelda- Hebrew Poet' to PR as a short, factual entry. I could add more information, and I also have a translated poem of hers that I wasn't sure would be suitable for a Guide entry, however I can add it in or link it to this entry.
Comments, as always, are welcome.


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 2

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned


Elly, you have a wonderful framework for your article. Please add more.

Is there anything more on the background to her writing?

What was she like as a person?

As for the poem, I will leave those with better knowledge than I, to advise whether it should be linked or posted.


lil xx
smiley - magic


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 3

Yael Smith

Thanks lil.smiley - smiley


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 4

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned

smiley - goodluck with this smiley - ok

lil xx


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 5

U168592

This is a great little Entry, and as lil said, just needs some fleshing out to give more of a picture of Zelda.

I for one would love to read some of the poetry and see why you were so inspired to write the Entry. As long as you don't include an entire poem in the Entry, and just a few stanzas, you should be fine in regards to copyright laws.

If you are worried, simply add a link to an appropriate website. Does she have a website dedicated to her?

Look forward to seeing this given a bit more, then I'm sure it would be included in the Edited Guide smiley - ok


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 6

Leo


Matt, is there anywhere it specifically mentions policy in regard to copyrit matters?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 7

Leo


I have to agree with everyone else. more more more - please! smiley - smileysmiley - ok

What themes does she usually explore? for exmaple.


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 8

U168592

Leo, try here first A53209 - but for further details -

http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/brunel/Writing-Copyright (in particualr the 'Insubstanial' section). smiley - ok


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 9

Yael Smith

Well, she used to write very personal poems, Leo.

The websites I could find about her were mostly in Hebrew, Matt, and inspiring poet that she was, it made me think long and hard to see if I wanted to write the entry at all, with all the translation involved.smiley - yikes

I'll add some more, I promise, and I will quote from her poem, which is usually read out in memorial services on Hollocaust days. I think the translation I've found is good enough, so I will put some quote blocks in.

Thanks for this,
Elly.


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 10

U168592

smiley - goodluck

Look forward to seeing what you do smiley - smiley


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 11

Leo


Should be interesting. I'll be lurking. smiley - ok


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 12

Leo


Are you Isreali then?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 13

Yael Smith

Yes I am.smiley - smiley
Why do you ask?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 14

Yael Smith

Fattened it up a bit, what do you think?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 15

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned


It's looking better smiley - ok

That first paragraph could do with being split up a little - makes it easier on the eye smiley - winkeye

It all needs tidying up a bit, but the content is there smiley - smiley


You have a link to 'here'.. perhaps you could link more easily to the word 'article' in the previous sentence? It would help to tidy that part of the paragraph.


I will check back again later.. smiley - hug


lil xx


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 16

Leo


The first paragraph should definitely be split up - not to be callous, but all those men!

I asked because I was wondering how you stumbled across her poetry otherwise. Also because I vaguely knew there was an Israeli besides Yael on h2g2, but didn't know who. (I like the country - did some hitchhiking there.) Pleased ta meetcha. smiley - biggrin

You insinuate that Zelda taught - where? and what?

Is it possible to include a couplet or a small excerpt from her stuff?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 17

Leo


*sneaks back and inserts "dead" before "men" in second sentence.*


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 18

Yael Smith

THANK YOU LIL!

smiley - run


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 19

Leo


That high school she attended - was it a Bais Yaakov?


A21423872 - Zelda- Hebrew Poet

Post 20

Yael Smith

I don't think so... I can check for you.


Key: Complain about this post