A Conversation for The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 21

Tenaka

Maybe, but even so to have so much of it in the two hours since the article was posted is nice, so I just wanted to add my thanks.

smiley - cheers


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 22

HappyDude

as I said it is looking good, and er.. no rush it has to be here at least 7 days before a scout can even think of picking it smiley - winkeye


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 23

Tenaka

I know, I know, but like to have it all nice and neat.
smiley - cheers


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 24

HappyDude

P.S.

Re: external links ... http://www.royal.gov.uk/smiley - winkeye

also ya might want to look up "Edgar the Atheling" for the Aftermath section...

*goes back to sipping smiley - redwine*


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 25

Tenaka

Yeah, I had thought about doing that, but I thought I might (as you liked the idea of it) do a whole piece on William and I'd put that in their. Still thinking about. I'm guessing you like history then considering all the pointers and now your devouring one of my sources for this article?


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 26

HappyDude

AKA Edgar Ætheling or Edgar the Outlaw


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 27

HappyDude

If ya want info on Edgar ... Wikipedia is far more useful than the Royal website smiley - winkeye


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 28

HappyDude

"I'm guessing you like history"

C919 14 articles, 5 with my name on them somewhere (although to be fare my contribution to 1 was minor) smiley - ermsmiley - smiley


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 29

HappyDude

Contempory Quotes

Don't know if ya want to use these, both form the Anglo Saxon Chronicles

Harold:
"He met little quiet as long as he ruled the realm"

William:
He was a very stern and violent man, so that no one dared do anything contary to his will...


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 30

Otto Fisch ("Stop analysing Strava.... and cut your hedge")


Great entry! smiley - biggrin A few comments for you:

1. I would think about taking out the first sentence - guide entries generally are supposed to be timeless or nearly timeless or something. Also, there's a rogue "I" in there.

2. I know this entry is about the Battle of Hastings, but I wonder if it's worth saying more about Harold's supposed declaration of loyalty. I think he had gone to William's court to bring back some hostages when he became shipwrecked and was held captive by another ruler (Burgandy?) before being freed on the orders of William. I think I read somewhere that he made Harold swear on a coloured box, and that he didn't know that it contained saints bones or something.

3. Is it worth mentioning Halley's Comet and the Bayeux Tapestry?

Otto


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 31

Pinniped


For those who don't mind novelisations and a few factual liberties, a really good telling is Julian Rathbone's "The Last English King".


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 32

Tenaka

I take the point with regard to being timeless, but I think the approach of the 1000 year point for possibly the single most important event in the History of these Isles, and the last succesful invasion of them, should be noted. I'll re read and have a think. I'll remove the rogue I though. With regard to the others, I might try and work Halley's Comet and the Bayeux Tapestry in, but not at the mo as a bit busy at work (my ususal Hootoo time). I would prefer not to add anymore additional history such as Harold's Oath, I just don't feel it neccessary. A whole series of pages would be needed to deal with the whole history behind and around William, Harold and Hardrada. There just isn't enough space to mention much else without bringing in lot more information and the piece becoming bogged down in lots of additional Historical facts, theories and influences (IMHO), unless they directly relate to the Battle.
Tenaka
smiley - cheers


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 33

HappyDude

Halley's Comet and the Bayeux Tapestry are probaly worth noting smiley - smiley

and as I noted earlier, as you did a small biog bit on William ("A Little About William"), Harold as the other main protagonist of this text should be treated to the same courtesy smiley - smiley

It's looking good smiley - ok


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 34

Tenaka

Maybe you're right about Harold, but that would mean doing a bit about King Hardrada as well. I suppose it's worth thinking about. I'll have a think and might add something when I get chance.

smiley - cheers


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 35

HappyDude

as ya primly talking about the battle of Hastings I'm not sure if there is a need to do the same for King Hardrada as he didn't actually participate in the said battle smiley - smiley


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 36

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

The only other thing I'd like to see a reference to is that there is now a small town/village at the site of the battle, around 5 miles from Hastings itself, called... Battle.

smiley - ale


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 37

Sam

This looks ripe for the picking! Is there anything yuo wnat to add, Tenaka? smiley - smiley


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 38

Tenaka

I'd like to put through a couple of the suggestions made.
I am generally happy with it though and will probable make those changes now!

Thanks

Tenaka
smiley - cheers


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 39

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

Nice entry.

Some typos and comments to be fixed:

' I thought it would be appropriate ' needs putting in the third person, eg, 'it seems appropriate'

King Hardrada - I've always heard him referred to as 'King Harold Hardrada'

support Williams claim > support William's claim

inherited his fathers mantle > inherited his father's mantle

furios > furious

lept > leapt

slipt > slipped

bailey5at > bailey5 at

HArold's Infantry > Harold's Infantry

trace there routes >trace their roots


smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A1302003 - The Battle of Hastings - October 14th 1066

Post 40

Tenaka

Thanks

Think it must be nearly done about now

Tenaka
smiley - cheers


Key: Complain about this post