A Conversation for Ice Hockey

ICE? Hockey

Post 1

tsi nobmort

What other kind is there? Yes, I know that some people run around on billiard table smooth
grass fields with strange little "J" shaped sticks hacking at a hard ball and each other's shins
but the word hockey only coincidentally appears in its name. Only people from the Southern
U.S.A., and, obviously, Guide editors feel the need to use the word "ice" when describing what
is REAL hockey. I promise you that no one will be confused if the word "ice" is omitted when
talking about the sport of hockey. (That's the kind played on ice, not the kind played on grass)


ICE? Hockey

Post 2

Maxx 43307

I agree on some levels. I am a huge fan of hockey and I don't belive that ICE is needed, but there are other kinds of hockey (and I don't mean filed hockey.) There is roller hockey, and street. I say we change the title to hockey and put a subpoint about street and roller hockey.


ICE? Hockey

Post 3

tsi nobmort

So it's agreed! Nice ruling the universe with you...


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 4

Armitage

I get to play the greatest game in the world tomorrow! We still have ice in canada eh!
(equipment just stinks worse in this heat, damn)


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 5

Dawd1

Now that it is all agreed, all that needs to be done is for a Committee to be selected, in order to ratify the terms under which the word Hockey may legally/morally apply. They can then peruse the legislation of the aforementioned agreement on 'Hockey', referring to Ice Hockey as we call it in the UK. The Committee can then simply draw up a proposal that can be set before the 10, 000 researchers, who after debating the next course of action, can take a referendum on the issue, as to wether or not the term Hockey should be submitted to the H2G2 editorial management team for rejection during the next few months.
Right then, agreed.
I thought when those 'j' shaped sticks were used it was called 'shinty'......


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 6

mrs. slartibartfast

but i don't agree. so where does that put all this?


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 7

Dawd1

If you'd like to just fill out these forms please Mrs S....
Actually, I don't agree either. Hockey is what girls play. Dropping the word Ice from the North American sport conjurs up images of young girls running around in very short pleated skirts letting all and sundry see their knickers.
I'll get me radiation suit.


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 8

mrs. slartibartfast

knickers? sundry? nothing to do with hockey at all. and i won't even discuss radiation suits, that's just silly.


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 9

Dawd1

that was a reference to the character on the Fast Show, who says something out of place, then says, " I'll get me coat " and leaves.


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 10

mrs. slartibartfast

pardon me then. not being from england, i've never heard of it. had i heard of it, i'm sure i would have thought it quite funny. and this has nothing to do with hockey.


Then HOCKEY it is! (not field, not street, not roller, only ice)

Post 11

mrs. slartibartfast

you realize i had to do the hockey bit again, as i find it rather amusing.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 12

Dawd1

Hockey Schmockey Mrs S. I was trying to read your interesting thesis on lentils and have to keep checking your replies. I'll never get to bed at this rate.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 13

mrs. slartibartfast

very sorry. and lentils have nothing to do with hockey.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 14

Maxx 43307

Though I do know of the British Version of Hockey, I still feel that it is better known as field hockey. Hockey (in many contries) refers to the stuff played on ice. This is not just because I am some dumb Canadian, but I belive that hockey is growing to be an international sport. Even Israel has its own hockey team. I feel that Ice Hockey is just a redundent statment. Feild hockey, roller hockey, etc. Defines the terms we are talking about.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 15

mrs. slartibartfast

hockey is as hockey does. nuff said.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 16

Dawd1

A few hours ago, I called round to see my nephews. They were in the garden playing with hockey sticks. I realised the oppurtunity and asked them what they were playing. They both replied "Hockey". I told them about the discussion on H2G2 and they said "there is street hockey, ice hockey and grass hockey (field hockey). This is just 'hockey'." So there. Football is football too. As in English Association Football, not gridiron. Australia have 'Australian Rules Football' , which differentiates their game. So Ice Hockey is Ice Hockey.


Hockey Schmockey

Post 17

mrs. slartibartfast

what about the nfl?


Hockey Schmockey

Post 18

Maxx 43307

It looks like all we can say is that North America is differnt than the UK, and Europe. We consider hockey, ice hockey, while you consider hockey field or whatever else. Football to you is soccer to us, and footbal to us is something close to rugby. Cricit to you is... well baseball is the closest thing but not really the same thing. Both can be rather dull. So the only answer is to leave it as Ice Hockey and keep the understanding that for North Americans, adding ice is redundent but because this is international then we should to make the distinction between this and field hockey.(Or any other hockey)


Hockey Schmockey

Post 19

johnnyr

Americans think that cricket
is baseball
on valium


Hockey Schmockey

Post 20

mrs. slartibartfast

i rather thought it was baseball on lithium. and what is a wicket googly? do tell.


Key: Complain about this post