A Conversation for 'Overprotected' by Britney Spears
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Ormondroyd Started conversation Aug 12, 2002
Brilliant, Abi. It's a shame that so many people fail to understand the hidden depths of supposedly 'shallow' chart pop, and I'm glad that you have made the effort to decode Britney.
I myself am planning an entry exploring the subtext of the philosopher-poet Minogue's 'Can't Get You Out Of My Head'. I think it's obvious that the song deals with the way that brand images and advertising slogans are constantly drummed into us, so that - in a very real sense - we can't get them out of our heads. Kylie's spirited but ultimately unsuccessful attempt to escape from her shirt in the video clearly symbolises the difficulty of trying to break free from such conditioning.
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Abi Posted Aug 12, 2002
It is about time Kylie and Britney were deconstructed! Thanks for the comments Ormy - of all the people who could have read this, I am glad it was you!
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Smij - Formerly Jimster Posted Aug 12, 2002
I'm wondering whether my entry on the deconstruction of four specific Kylie tracks is worth it now. Ormy said everything I possibly could
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Dr E Vibenstein (You know it is, it really is.) Posted Aug 12, 2002
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Swoosh - maker of puddings, keeper of dribbly pets, known for disappearing frequently Posted Aug 16, 2002
Chainsaw!!
These people may well have deep inner emotional thoughts but that's not what they are famous for and certainly not the image they push across. And do they actually write their songs? Overprotected is ridiculous! The girl is a pop star and that sort of life is definately not sheltered. How can we be expected to take these people seriously if they do not show us they can do more then sing a couple of songs and wear practically nothing in front of half the world!!!
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Saturnine Posted Sep 8, 2002
Have to agree there folks. How can you deconstruct something that isnt there? What is Britney? A Corporate image, the all-American girl (maybe all too much...!), a microphone, a psuedo sex-symbol (she aint no Marilyn Monroe or Betty Page, is she?)...how can you deconstruct something that essentially isnt there? Everything mentioned (in the very-well written piece may I add!) doesnt exist! I obtained a very good quote from one Ms. Spears...*Its only music. It isnt what I feel* (Im paraphrasing a little I think!) Her music is written by underpaid musicians because record companies rarely sign anything but vacuous 5-minutes-of-famers, more than likely older males, that gets cut down and mass produced.
Deep and meaningful it aint.
Kylie however is a different kettle of fish. You only have to look at her mid-90's efforts to know that she's at least attempted to be an artist.
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Ormondroyd Posted Sep 11, 2002
'It's all a pile of words'? I've often said something very similar about Britney's records.
(s off to hide with Abi)
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Dr E Vibenstein (You know it is, it really is.) Posted Sep 11, 2002
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
Saturnine Posted Sep 15, 2002
Hmm.
Maybe it was something similar...perhaps a word beginning with *t*?
I don't know. My memory escapes me...
Key: Complain about this post
Britney and Kylie: the semiotics
- 1: Ormondroyd (Aug 12, 2002)
- 2: Abi (Aug 12, 2002)
- 3: Smij - Formerly Jimster (Aug 12, 2002)
- 4: Dr E Vibenstein (You know it is, it really is.) (Aug 12, 2002)
- 5: Swoosh - maker of puddings, keeper of dribbly pets, known for disappearing frequently (Aug 16, 2002)
- 6: Saturnine (Sep 8, 2002)
- 7: Abi (Sep 9, 2002)
- 8: Saturnine (Sep 11, 2002)
- 9: Ormondroyd (Sep 11, 2002)
- 10: Dr E Vibenstein (You know it is, it really is.) (Sep 11, 2002)
- 11: Ormondroyd (Sep 11, 2002)
- 12: Saturnine (Sep 15, 2002)
More Conversations for 'Overprotected' by Britney Spears
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."