A Conversation for What Constitutes a Fair Tax?

fairness

Post 1

marshdom

a marginal rate of tax on income would be unfair if it exceeded 49%.
it is surely immoral if someone else takes the majority of the money you earn by the sweat of your labour. Isn't the worker worth his pay; he ought at least to retain the barest majority of his earnings.
the current marginal rate of tax on earnings for a person earning
£ 100,000 is in in excess of 70%, i.e. earn £ 10 keep only £ 3, earn £ 10,000, keep less than £ 3,000.
that's 11.34% paid by your employer in NI out of the £10,000 you earned him, 1% paid by you, 40% tax, and 20% tax clawed back via loss of your tax code. Next tax year, you and your employer each pay an extra 1% each, taking your loss to 3/4 of your extra earnings. If you've got any brains you'll vote the only way that works - with your feet.


fairness

Post 2

KB

One of the biggest factors in whether a tax is fair has nothing to do with how high the rate is; it's what you get for your money. I wouldn't worry too much about a 100% rate of tax if it meant I didn't have to pay for anything after that - but I'd object strongly to even a 1% rate of income tax if the only thing it went towards was a queen or president's private art collection.


Key: Complain about this post

fairness

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more