A Conversation for The Three Ages of Music
to read? or not to read?
Kittybriton Started conversation Dec 28, 2006
I was thinking about the argued question of whether to read the music you are playing, or play from memory/by ear/imagination and it occurred to me that music is a lot like cooking in that when you don't know the recipe well, it helps to follow it in writing.
So most of the time, if you can boil water without a recipe, you can play a tune without the score
to read? or not to read?
Recumbentman Posted Dec 29, 2006
Hello Kitty. I know that people have very habitual attitudes to reading; I feel myself that once the score has nothing more to tell you you should stop looking at it. A lot of people simply don't know where else to look. In this connection I like to quote Couperin who said "Look at your audience, as though you were occupied with nothing else".
The only attempt at a counter-argument that I have seen is from a pianinst who remarked that a certain string of minim chords (in a Beethoven sonata? can't remember) had a wonderfully calming look to them, or something like that.
Key: Complain about this post
to read? or not to read?
More Conversations for The Three Ages of Music
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."