This is a Journal entry by Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Captain Haddock

Post 61

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Well, IMO it's like this. As soon as photons have reached you, you're an observer (whether or not you've looked at them or not). Now in relativity simultaneity breaks down as well, so for any two causally related events it is possible to choose a reference frame where they are arbitrarily close to being "simultaneous". This means that downstream causality *cannot* travel faster than light because that means in some reference frames it will be *upstream* causality. In fact it will in all, but in some the "effect" event will still happen "after" the "cause" event. OK so far? Good.

Now, supposing that photons (and other luminal intermediary particles) are the carriers of causality. In fact this is suggested by QM, and moreover it is suggested that until information is received about an event, in a crucial sense, *it has not happened*. This may be the same as saying that until you pass through an event's trailing light cone, it is unresolved, and this is fine because in some reference frames it actually *hasn't* happened yet.

In other words, a partial combination of relativity and QM may help answer one of QM's nastiest philosophical problems. Right now I'm reading up on Quantum Field Theory so I can do this properly.

Oh, and *don't tell anybody about this*!


Captain Haddock

Post 62

Vip

I couldn't, I'm afraid. I will have to read it a few times more to get the hang of it!


Captain Haddock

Post 63

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

I'll draw a picture of that, too ....


Captain Haddock

Post 64

Vip

Ah! Got it now!


Captain Haddock

Post 65

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Heyy!

I think it's quite neat, how think you?

Technically it's also BBC copyright now, but screw 'em.


Captain Haddock

Post 66

Vip

Yeah, it's good. I had to read it a few times, but that's quantum for you. It's *supposed* to be complicated.


Captain Haddock

Post 67

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

in a very Zenlike way

I think Quantum Mechanics is the universe's way of telling us that it's way better at making jokes than we will ever be.

That and deep sea fish.


Captain Haddock

Post 68

Vip

that is the best answer to 'why, dammit, why??' I've ever heard. God sticking two fingerrs up and saying 'in still cleverer than you'!


Captain Haddock

Post 69

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Well, funnier. And always in a nice way. Probably.

One of the weirdest things about my being in love situation aforementioned was that I would occasionally think the most ridiculous thoughts like

Why doesn't she love me? I'd be so happy if she did. But hang on. Someone else might love her too. Then, if she loved me, she wouldn't love him. And that would devastate him.

Poor guy.

Hang on, that's me!

I nearly embodied that in a cartoon strip ... it did actually make me laugh. Weird but good.


Captain Haddock

Post 70

Vip

It's funny, isn't it, how your brain does things like that. Trouble is, I wouldn't get as far as the 'that's me!' bit and end up feeling guilty for someone else!


Captain Haddock

Post 71

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Driving a train of thought through the buffers of reason is possibly my favourite pastime.

I should really edit that and use it in preciously witty conversation in the hope that someone will quote me. An old old friend of mine used to say the same aphorism over and again in the hope, I genuinely believe, that he'd make it into a "wit and wisdom" collection in 100 years' time. I can no longer recall what it might have been.


Captain Haddock

Post 72

Vip

Put in on your Space. Right at the top. I've done a similar thing, but I think only clarinettists will find it funny. Ah well.


Captain Haddock

Post 73

Andrew Wyld [kt:'Burning Pestle', kp:'Mutamems, Ideodiversity', Zaph.]

Good plan ... it goes on tomorrow. Although I think a journal entry would be better. I'm quite proud of some of my shorter ones ("Aftermath" being the most recent).


Captain Haddock

Post 74

Vip

I will have to have a look...


Key: Complain about this post