This is the Message Centre for bobstafford
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
Bluebottle Started conversation Jul 8, 2016
A87874889 The Stewarts. James I And VI, Comes To The English Throne – Version I'm Mucking Up
A87793960 The Stewarts. James I And VI, Comes To The English Throne – Original
Just letting you know I'll be sub-editing this entry – I'll be popping back with questions later on, but in the meantime please subscribe.
<BB<
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
bobstafford Posted Jul 8, 2016
good job
there is a stray "." that should be a "," but I can not find it again
but that is all.
How was it for content?
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
Bluebottle Posted Jul 8, 2016
Still working my way through it, but I'll keep my eye out.
The way it works is that once an entry is picked from Peer Review, a duplicate copy is created. This copy is then assigned to a sub-editor (in this case me) who then can edit it. That's the stage we're at here.
After it is edited it is checked by the author for their final approval, which once it has received is returned to be finally checked by one of the Guide Editors and then joins the queue to get to the front page.
<BB<
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
Bluebottle Posted Jul 11, 2016
You'll be pleased to know that I've made far fewer changes than to the first two entries of yours I subbed.
I've added links where appropriate, tweaked a couple of spellings and grammar and tried to cut down on the number of footnotes. I'll summarise the main changes here:
Opening: I've added the banner at the top.
The opening paragraph is virtually identical.
King James: His Path to the Throne of England: Virtually identical, I just combined the first and second paragraphs.
Henry VII of England and his wife Elizabeth of York: I've changed the list of children into chronological order.
I added a 'Mary, Queen of Scots' section to incorporate the text listed next to 'Margaret' as well as the information in the Mary Stewart/Stuart spelling footnote.
James' Early Years In Scotland A few tweaks to the paragraphs and title
A new section entitled 'Regency' has been added to break up this section, with the regents in subheadings.
Marriage I've moved the section on James getting married here, where it fits better chronologically. Except for the mention of Tycho.
Ascension of the first King of Great Britain I tweaked the title (but can tweak it back if you want)
I tried to cut down the number of footnotes in this section to improve the flow.
I moved some material from James' journey to London in the following section here, so there's a clearer 'before King of England/after King of England' break.
A Dutiful Son? This section moved up from the end to be more in chronological order, and so that 'Legacy' is the last part of the entry.
As always, feel free to let me know your comments on the entry so far, what you'd like me to change/restore/add to and delete, and I'll go through the changes made to the rest of the entry tomorrow.
<BB<
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
bobstafford Posted Jul 11, 2016
You have changed a few things and it is all for the better, some times it is hard to get things just right, well done good work
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
Bluebottle Posted Jul 12, 2016
Rest of the changes:
James: King and Scholar This now begins with his coronation, with the Privy Council section moved up into the previous section.
The second paragraph in this section has been split into two, and the section about Scotland has been moved to fit with his policies on Ireland and America rather than in the coronation paragraph.
Section 'A Dutiful Son' has moved down since yesterday to become a subsection of 'James: King and Scholar' which I think is the ideal chronological fit.
The section after this has become named 'Patron of the Arts' and now includes the section on Tycho Brahe from earlier.
The mention of the Bible and witches leads neatly into:
The Witch Hunts: Other than the movement of the Marriage section upwards, there are only minor tweaks.
The Big Bang in Theory The list of conspirators is now in a footnote.
The information in the previous footnote about Elizabeth has been summarised in the text as all this information is in the entry on Elizabeth.
The information in the previous footnote 15 is now incorporated into the text.
Legacy: Almost identical, with the paragraph on Mary now moved into the 'A Dutiful Son' subsection of 'James: King and Scholar'
So that's it. I hope you don't think I've made too many changes – feel free to object to anything I've done and ask me to change stuff back. Have a thorough read through and let me know what you think, if there's anything in the body of the text, or titles, that you'd like me to tweak, delete, change or alter in a final thorough read-through, and let me know what you'd like me to fix or if it meets your full approval.
<BB<
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
bobstafford Posted Jul 12, 2016
You have not changed the content just shuffened the cards into a different order.
Works well from me,
well done
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
Bluebottle Posted Jul 13, 2016
Okay then, I've pressed the button to send it into the next queue!
I look forward to seeing more Stuart/Stewart entries.
<BB<
Key: Complain about this post
Subbing James I & VI on the Throne
- 1: Bluebottle (Jul 8, 2016)
- 2: bobstafford (Jul 8, 2016)
- 3: Bluebottle (Jul 8, 2016)
- 4: Bluebottle (Jul 11, 2016)
- 5: bobstafford (Jul 11, 2016)
- 6: Bluebottle (Jul 12, 2016)
- 7: bobstafford (Jul 12, 2016)
- 8: Bluebottle (Jul 13, 2016)
- 9: h2g2 Guide Editors (Sep 12, 2016)
- 10: Bluebottle (Sep 13, 2016)
- 11: bobstafford (Sep 13, 2016)
More Conversations for bobstafford
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."