This is the Message Centre for aka Bel - A87832164

Cliches and stereotypes

Post 21

aka Bel - A87832164

The Emperor Wilhelm song, Dmitri? smiley - rofl


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 22

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

Outsiders associate those helmets with Norwegians, Bel. We assume that anyone who wears one says, 'bork, bork, bork.' smiley - tongueincheek

smiley - roflYep. Singing about Kaiser Wilhelm now.

Icy, the song goes, 'We want our old Kaiser Wilhelm back, the one with the long beard...'

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWJOkzLBPak


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 23

h5ringer

Interesting, thanks Bel. I never knew the correct name was Pickelhaube. I've always known a 'Pickel' as a pimple, and a 'Haube' as a bonnetsmiley - yikes Don't you just love compound nouns?


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 24

Pierre de la Mer ~ sometimes slightly worried but never panicking ~

Don't get me started! smiley - evilgrin

Being a borderline kraut (and proud of it - as well as thankful for the fact that I can write it here now without old Auntie Beeb interfering) I am allowed to make as much fun of both the Krauts and the Danes as I bloody well choose. smiley - cool

Just like my Jewish friends can tell whatever Jewish joke they like (which I for obvious reasons can't...)


Q: What do you call a person who smiley - thiefs from all his neighbours?

A: A kleptoman

Q: And what do you call a person who burns people's houses down?

A: A pyroman

Q: And what do you call a person who does both?

A: A German...

smiley - pirate

PS: Yes, I know it's really kleptomaniac and pyromaniac, but not in Germany and Denmark and you get the joke anyway smiley - biggrin


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 25

aka Bel - A87832164

smiley - rofl

That was a new one to me, Pierce. smiley - biggrin


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 26

Icy North

The best Jewish joke I heard was told to me by an Arab.

Sadly, I cannot repeat it here, and in any case it requires actions.


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 27

Willem

It works in Afrikaans too (piromaan, kleptomaan, Germaan).


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 28

Willem

Sorry smiley - simposted with Icy North there!


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 29

Jabberwock


http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00lvdcm


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 30

Vestboy

There was recently a BBC radio series about a virtual museum where people could add exhibits. Harry Enfield asked to have a room for stupid Germans... because he didn't know any. He went on to list the clever and talented Germans that he knew. I was a bit nervous of what he was going to say when he announced the room to begin with, but then thought it may be going a bit far to say there are none.


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 31

aka Bel - A87832164

Lots of them around, I'm afraid. He'd fill the room in no time.


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 32

Pierre de la Mer ~ sometimes slightly worried but never panicking ~

Germany's borders have changed a lot over the years (and even the earliest are rather young) and it is futile to discuss what parts of Europe are "genuinely German".

Let's look at the German speaking people instead. About 100 million have German as their native tongue I reckon.

If you see it this way it is no surprise that a lot of very clever people emerged from this group of humans: Johan Wolfgang von Goethe, Friedrich Nietzsche, Karl Marx, Sigmund Freud, Sophie Scholl, Anne-Sophie Mutter to name but a few.

And likewise it is no surprise that this group also fostered quite a few not so clever individuals.

Seeing things this way makes us Germans seem almost human, don't you think? smiley - tongueout

smiley - pirate


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 33

Pierre de la Mer ~ sometimes slightly worried but never panicking ~

Stereotype: Germans have no humour

Rubbish! Just because it's so different from yours that you don't understand it doesn't mean it isn't funny. Even in the most remote areas of for instance The Black Forest you will find laughing Germans smiley - biggrin

(the stereotype is valid for the French also, by the way smiley - tongueout)

smiley - pirate


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 34

Nosebagbadger {Ace}

Stereotype: Germans can't talk unless something is going wrong
and the British are never happy unless something is going wrong


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 35

Pierre de la Mer ~ sometimes slightly worried but never panicking ~

I guess that's why both nations always talk about the weather smiley - biggrin

smiley - pirate


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 36

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

About 'Germans': There's a diaspora, you know. smiley - winkeye

If 'German' is taken to mean 'people who have German as their first language, and a culture that originated in Central Europe', then I've known Germans who were born in Siberia, Transylvania, and Pennsylvania.

I think there are some in Texas, too. smiley - whistle


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 37

KB

Question, though: isn't the linguistic boundary of what constitutes "German" just as fluid (and as recent a development) as the political boundary on maps?


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 38

Dmitri Gheorgheni, Post Editor

Now, that's true for you. smiley - smiley How low is Low German? It's often a political question.

On the other hand, it could just be fun:

http://hiwwewiedriwwe.wordpress.com/


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 39

KB

What's interesting is that I often come across a different dialect and realise I can understand it much easier than the Hochdeutsch I studied for years.


Cliches and stereotypes

Post 40

Pierre de la Mer ~ sometimes slightly worried but never panicking ~

There was no German state until 1871. The Bundesrepublik was formed in 1949. This merged with the area formerly knowns as The German Democratic Republik in 1999.

Borders are a ridiculous invention, but there they are so we have to learn to live with them just like religions and hiphop. That's okay, at my age you have to choose your defeats carefully smiley - biggrin

As for language borders well, most of us here speak indo-german, if I'm not very much mistaken (which I might be, I'm not a filologist after all)

Of course there is a diaspora. I guess most European languages have diasporasses scattered around the globe

"Die Neger in Ostafrika
sie rufen all zu gleich:
Wir wollen Deutsche Neger sein
- wir wollen heim ins Reich!"

Just to give you an example smiley - biggrin

smiley - pirate


Key: Complain about this post