h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

Hi. Sorry to ask this out of the blue but, I have written a guide entry on the Ninth Doctor, since you seem to be a doctor who fan i was wondering if you would be so kind as to tell me wether it's good enough for peer review or not? The Guide ID is : A5001959 I would apreciate your advice.

Hi there,

Sorry for taking so long to get back to you. I like the article. Actually as long as it is, I felt like I wanted more. The one thing I'm not sure is all that relevant is the bit where you compare the Doctor's duration as the Doctor... now I know what you mean, but pedants would say that in number of episodes that Paul McGann is the shortest... though obviously he was left holding the keys for the longest amount of time... And I would prefer not to compare to the comedy sketch (as much as I like Rowan Atkinson, I like to think of the two as completely seperate entities).

But I really like that you've mentioned how much the Doctor needs Rose, and even loves her. I thought this too. Its a very clear theme running through the series.

All in all I like it. Just a warning though, if you put it in to peer review, they can be quite harsh, and at the very least will probably tell you to stick a bit of text saying "spoiler", on it somewhere.

But thanks for showing me this. I'm honoured that you came to me.

Cheers,
Terran

It’s quite alright! I’m glad you wrote back at all! And I’m also glad you liked it. As for Paul McGann I totally forgot about him!!!! I’m sure someone’s going to mention it. I posted it on peer review, spur of the moment yesterday! As for the Rowan Atkinson thing I only mentioned it because I had a feeling if I didn’t someone would point it out! Now I’m very nervous! Oh well I can always alter it If it gets refused and changes it. I thought I had to mention the Doctor and Rose thing, for me it’s an essential element to his personality in the series.