This is the Message Centre for Tilly - back in mauve

Salmon of doubt

Post 1

Lost & Found Rhino

On one of the conversation forums I notice that you where reading salmon of doubt. Is it worth getting the hardback or should I get the cheapo paper on specail offer.

Cheers
Rhino


Salmon of doubt

Post 2

Tilly - back in mauve

Well, Salmon of Doubt, as I've seen it, is a a nice compilation of DNA's short stories plus the unfinished script of the so-named story itself. I myself am a sucker for hardback books, and since I often return to read the short stories there, I notice it doesn't wear just as fast.

But as far as I know the texts in the two versions doesn't differ, so I guess it's just a question of what you like yourself smiley - smiley


Salmon of doubt

Post 3

Lost & Found Rhino

Sorry Tilly ,
Having re read the question I asked , I feel that I didn't phrase it very well.smiley - huh What I really should have said was.

Is it a good enough read to keep re-reading it often and hence justify the hardback version , or is is more of a once read then keep in the bookcase?
But thanks for the speedy reply smiley - ta

Cheers
Rhino


Salmon of doubt

Post 4

Tilly - back in mauve

No need to appologize smiley - smiley

Well, the Salmon of Doubt story itself I only read once - it was a bit too frustrating reading a story you know there'll never be a proper ending on smiley - bigeyes While the added essays and short stories I've read several times now, because many of them are so funny I need a little laugh to brighten up an otherwise bleak day...

But I don't feel I can decide for you - I can only say the hardback copy worked out very well for me as I am one of those persons who read good stories again and again and again... smiley - geek


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Tilly - back in mauve

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more