This is the Message Centre for mamuomar

You in Peer Review

Post 1

Secretly Not Here Any More

I didn't want to give you the oxygen of publicity in PR, because every time you pop up with a snide comment or a jab, you seem to get a sad little thrill out of it. Here however, where enthusiastic young writers can't see it, I won't hesitate to tell you just what I think.

Wolfsubzero's entry on Immortality isn't a classic piece of literature. It's not even good enough to go into the guide yet, but that's due to his inexperience as a writer. What he lacks in writing prowess though, he makes up for in enthusiasm - and if he's willing to take advice on board then hopefully he'll have his name on a good EG entry.

What he doesn't need is someone like you rushing in, calling him a "moron" and that his attempts aren't welcome. Because that's rude, unhelpful and downright nasty.

I've seen you in a few threads, and your attitude to the writers on this site stinks. I suppose it's because you've had a submission knocked back? Well here's some friendly advice, dispensed free of charge. Adopt Wolfsubzero's attitude, drop this Mr. Nasty act and write something worth reading - be it a review of an entry or a guide entry of your own.

If not, please stay out of Peer Review.

Thanks,

Psyc.


You in Peer Review

Post 2

mamuomar

Point taken I can be snide

Most of the time I'm reading this stuff its at work because work tends to just be simple mundane tasks

Although I do take on board your point I have to notify you that I have given positive feedback that has helped entries get far

eg the entry on wolfenstein

obviously by an inexpereienced one

why don't i write too many entries?

i spend a lot of time writing fiction

it doesn't get in here

smiley - choc

4u?


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for mamuomar

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more