A Conversation for The Alternative Writing Workshop

A16939416 - Brainery Tomfoolery

Post 1

AT

Entry: Brainery Tomfoolery - A16939416
Author: amaranthine_trail - U2233701

My second attempt after a year. Feel free to critique.


A16939416 - Brainery Tomfoolery

Post 2

LL Waz


What a very condensed account of a day! It worked in the sense of portraying that.

Critique stuff, since you ask and aren't charging -

Some neat images - parallel strips, elastic faces, chalked square... liked those a lot.

The atmosphere comes through strongly - comfortable office, maybe slightly stuffy, life passing by outside, good lunch...

The narrator - he/she seems, erm, a little on the self-satisfied side. I didn't exactly engage with him/her and have the impression he/she's an observer of life themself.

Overall reaction - not a strong one, it was like looking at an interesting but not personally engaging picture in a gallery.

That first sentence was a bit offputting - I nearly didn't read past it. It's taken a while to work out why but I think it's the parallel combined with lateral. Lateral's just repeating the idea isn't it? In a sentence, right at the beginning where you're already asking the reader to do quite a lot of work.

Can I ask why 'spewed'? Seems an odd choice with contentment and soft light either side, and I think influenced my view of the narrator - why's he/she content surrounded by walls he/she sees as spewed on?...

All in all, interesting to work through.
Waz


A16939416 - Brainery Tomfoolery

Post 3

U1250369


smiley - book


Key: Complain about this post

A16939416 - Brainery Tomfoolery

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more