A Conversation for The Jefferson State Rebellion

Peer Review : A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 1

8584330

Entry: The State of Jefferson - A28880445
Author: Happy Nerd - U8584330

The Jefferson State patriotic rebellion.


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 2

TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office

The sort of stuff h2g2 was made for. Love it.

TRiG.smiley - ok


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 3

Vip

Fantastic. I'd never even heard of this until now.

No comments to add, I'm afraid, but that's because I liked it. Nothing in there stopped my enjoyment apart from the word gubernatorial which I looked up and found out you had used correctly. smiley - ok

smiley - fairy


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 4

Rev Nick

* a footnote perhaps, where "stacked the deck" is involved. Some may not understand the reference

<> (3rd word after California)

(love the idea of Klamath aligning and joing Portugal smiley - winkeye)

And I love the final quote, "a little rebellion now and then ...". It has toppled states, provinces and even web-sites. smiley - laugh

A really enjoyable read again


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 5

Z

Great entry smiley - ok

I have two (small) comments.

The entry opens with a Blockquote describing a proclaimation of independence. I was really unsure when this happened! It could have been any time from 1910 to 2010, and I do think that it would benefit from a date.

I would also alter the title - to something along the lines of 'The State of Jefferson - rebellion and protest'


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 6

8584330

Thank you, TRiG, Vip, Rev Nick, and Dr Zen for giving this entry a review. smiley - biggrin

Rev Nick: A "stacked the deck" footnote has been added, as has the missing word.

Dr Zen: The date was (and still is) part of the blockquote. To address this, I changed the formatting within the Proclamation of Independence to improve readability.

After briefly toying with the idea of calling the entry 'Jefferson - The Jackassable State' I settled on 'The Jefferson State Rebellion' as a title.

smiley - smiley
Happy Nerd


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 7

Amy Pawloski, aka 'paper lady'--'Mufflewhump'?!? click here to find out... (ACE)

Too bad the first title wouldn't've made itsmiley - laugh

I'm very glad I shanghaied... er, talked you into writing this. I couldn't've written anything nearly as good.

(Firefox actually recognizes "shanghaied" smiley - laugh)


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 8

8584330

Aw, shucks.smiley - blushsmiley - laugh

Did you tell the Northwestern h2g2 researcher's club to come here to PR?


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 9

Amy Pawloski, aka 'paper lady'--'Mufflewhump'?!? click here to find out... (ACE)

I have now, though I think most the members have elvisedsmiley - sadface


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 10

h5ringer

Terrific entry HN. A great read to start 2011 smiley - cheers


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 11

BMT

Another little gem for the EG, well done HN. smiley - ok


BMT Scout


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 12

8584330

Thank you, h5ringer, and BMT.

Amy, perhaps you could announce to them that due to their unresponsiveness you might have to secede from the Northwestern h2g2 researcher group, taking with you the counties of Curry, Josephine, and Jackson. That might get their attention. smiley - winkeye


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 13

Amy Pawloski, aka 'paper lady'--'Mufflewhump'?!? click here to find out... (ACE)

The thing is, I don't think anyone's south of Marionsmiley - laugh


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 14

Elentari

smiley - lurk


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 15

AlexAshman


Sorry to rock the boat, but I think that opening quote should be in italics. Also, to quote the English Usage page: >>>make quote marks singles (') not doubles ("), as it saves space and looks nicer.<<<

Otherwise, very interesting smiley - smiley


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 16

8584330

Didn't we start out that way? I do too it actually makes it look like the original.


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 17

8584330

Italics in place now.

How do we deal with embedded quotes? Don't we alternate as a rule?


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 18

AlexAshman


There's no specific guide to embedded quotes, but generally you're right that a quote within quoted material should be not-italicised.


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 19

8584330

Eureka:

Make quote marks singles (') not doubles ("), as it saves space and looks nicer6. Quotes within quotes should be double quotes, of course - and GuideML tag attributes7 always require double quotes for them to work.


A28880445 - The State of Jefferson

Post 20

8584330

Okay, the only double quotes left are the ones within a quote, as per the guidance above. smiley - ok


Key: Complain about this post