A Conversation for Magic - The Gathering

Nice Entry

Post 1

The researcher formerly known as binky

Great concise write up on Magic. Pleased to see it make it into the guide.

Neil.
(former Operations Manager, Wizards of the Coast UK)


Nice Entry

Post 2

The Cow

As an (ex) player of Magic, I love the fact that the wizard is named 'Tim'.


Just my own opinion...

Post 3

The Cow

It does however seem a bit too much like a rulebook.


Just my own opinion...

Post 4

Oscar

More than just rules... some stuff about the environment as well... not enough of the stuff that I'd really like to see though which is the inevitable amusing anecdotes about that time you Mishras Groundbreakered a plains into a 3/3 creature, made if fly, giant growthed it and killed the other guys Shivan dragon with it smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 5

The Cow

And only a passing reference to the infinite recursion deck!


Just my own opinion...

Post 6

Oscar

which one?
I had a great deck that used Aluren, Soul Keeper(?) and Shrieking Drake to gain infinite life and then killed the other guys deck by using Jesters Cap on it again and again and again smiley - smiley
Kind of infinite recursion I guess.

For those interested the combo was:
Play an aluren so that creatures which cost less than 3 mana can be played for free.
Play a soul keeper which gives you an extra hit point whenever a creature is played.
Play a shrieking drake which forces you to return a creature to your hand when it is played.

So you play the shrieking drake and return it to your hand and point out diplomatically to your opponent that you are happy to repeat this until you have 50000000000 life or he can just acknowledge that he is not going to do enough damage to kill you smiley - smiley

I beat Chris Manners with this deck! He was number 1 in the UK at the time! (I think)


Just my own opinion...

Post 7

Lupa Mirabilis, Serious Inquisitor

Is it really legal to return the Drake itself to your hand? Seems to me it isn't technically a creature until _after_ it comes into play.

But then if you had two Drakes, you could get around that anyway.


Just my own opinion...

Post 8

The Jester (P. S. of Village Idiots, Muse of Comedians, Keeper of Jokes, Chef and Seraph of Bad Jokes) LUG @ A458228

You didn't mention artifact creatures or colorless (sic) mana. BTW, what colour decks do you guys use? I use green/white with a couple of other coloured cards.

3smiley - biggrin

JOTD: I used to be indecisive, but now I'm not so sure.


Just my own opinion...

Post 9

The Cow

Infinite recursion deck:
Swords to plowshares: removes an opponents card from game, gives him life.
Some card I can't remember: all cards in graveyard come back to library
Shed loads of counter spells (et al)

The other player gains 10000s life, but loses cards. It comes under 'getting the other player so p***ed of that they give up crying' smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 10

Oscar

Felmets staff or something?
you wave it and your graveyard goes "BOING" back into your library smiley - smiley
lots of fun while it was legal smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 11

The Cow

No, it did both players... ans it was tornament legal


Just my own opinion...

Post 12

The researcher formerly known as binky

Feldon's Cane, though there are others (Thran Foundry springs to mind)

Neil
(DCI Level III Judge (retired))

"If Magic is your crutch, cast it aside and learn to walk without it!"
(actual Magic card flavour text smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 13

Oscar

Me and Ben and Jack used to play a game where you had to say the flavour text whenever you played a card and if any of the other players didn't name the card before the flavour text was finished they took five damage smiley - smiley

made cards like goblin bomb a bit more playable anyway smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 14

Oscar

we printed our own cards as well... like Mishras Tuckshop smiley - smiley
It was a land that you could tap to produce 1 colourless mana or tap and sacrifice to make target player go and buy chocolate and crisps for you smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 15

The Cow

We had Tragic: The gathering.

Including 'The Sheep of Doom'

Mishras Tuckshop reminds me of a real card - 2, Tap: Target player buys you target drink.
Errata: you pay any costs incurred.

Why isn't it tournament legal? smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 16

Oscar

Thats an unglued card isn't it?

our version was waaaay before that came out smiley - smiley


Just my own opinion...

Post 17

The Cow

Unglued? Yes.

Definity 'glued' was Chaos Confetti. A 'house' (or school) rule was that another, Chaos confetti shaped piece of paper could -not- be used. But, if the player had an entire (albeit glued together) chaos confetti, it could be played.


Just a few questions...

Post 18

cafram - in the states.

Oooooh! I'm all interested and stuff now...just a few quick q's though (for anyone who deigns to answer....)
Is it really expensive to get started?
How long do 'normal' games take?
How many ppl can play at once?
Ta muchly!
Cafram smiley - winkeye


Just a few questions...

Post 19

Oscar

It's not expensive to get started but it is very expensive to keep playing smiley - smiley
Normal games take from 10 minutes to 2 hours depending on the "blueness" of the decks involved.
Most TCGs have variations where any number of people can play, there are usually lots of different fun ways to try.

Hope this helps smiley - smiley


Just a few questions...

Post 20

cafram - in the states.

ta muchly! smiley - winkeye


Key: Complain about this post