A Conversation for Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Peer Review: A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 1

cuttlefish2

Entry: Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis - A3431170
Author: cuttlefish2 - U1206902

Yeah, cuttlefish rule!!!


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 2

Hoovooloo

Hmm. Bit short.

And inaccurate.

"The Cuttlefish is a truly extraordinary species of fish"

No it isn't. Koala bears aren't bears, prairie dogs aren't dogs, and cuttlefish aren't fish.

Cuttlefish, like octopuses, squid, slugs and snails, are molluscs.

And "considered to be intelligent" by whom? Is there evidence for this? I'm aware of evidence for the intelligence of certain species of octopus, but I wasn't aware the cuttlefish is particularly bright.

This entry is really a bit light on detail as it stands. Where do cuttlefish live? How big do they get? Can you eat them? Would you want to? Are they poisonous? Can you keep them in an aquarium? What do they eat? Do they, in fact, rule? smiley - winkeye

H.


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 3

Woodpigeon

Hi cuttlefish2,

Interesting entry! smiley - ok I think you have the bones of a fascinating Edited Entry here, definitely. I would agree with Hoo, in that you probably need a bit more padding. I would be interested in knowing where they are found, who are their relatives, and how long they live. It may also be useful to think about giving your paragraphs some headers - we can guide you through how to spruce this up later!

Good work!

smiley - peacedoveWoodpigeon


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 4

Gnomon - time to move on

And speaking of bones, what about cuttlefish bones? Where would budgies be without them?

Cuttlefish are members of the Cephalopods (a type of mollusc), along with octopuses, squids and the rare nautilus.


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 5

redpeckhamthegreatpompomwithnobson

They are considered a delicacy in many countries in Europe. And I heard they're quick to learn - so intelligent. Yes this entry could be much longer and more informative


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 6

Speller - If I can help somebody...

Yes - no entry on Cuttle Fish would be complete without mention of the humble Budgie! smiley - chick (Still no Budgie Smiley!!!)

Couple of typos (I know there's more to be done than niggle at a few typos though!)

3rd para "camouflage teh cuttlefish" -> camouflage the cuttlefish

3rd para "small oart of" -> small part of

Come back and have a go at this entry - there's a lot you could do with it! smiley - cheerup

Speller smiley - dog


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 7

the_jon_m - bluesman of the parish

I think that cuttlefish are really iteresting and there is so much to say about them. We have a great entry about the octopus,
http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/alabaster/A2818659

can you have a look at it and see if you can pick up any ideas for expanding on this entry

cheers

tjm


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

Hi The_Jon_M!

You don't have to put the full address when linking to another entry in a conversation. Just the A number will do, like this: A2818659


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 9

the_jon_m - bluesman of the parish

I know, I was just double click - copy - pasting, and it was quicker that way, less chance of the boss noticing


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 10

Emmily ~ Roses are red, Peas are green, My face is a laugh, But yours is a scream

smiley - erm cuttlefish2 hasn't posted since December 2004, does that mean he/she has Elvised? And is also a one stop Researcher, as this has the basis for a good Entry, does that mean it gets moved to Flea Market? smiley - smiley

Emmily
smiley - bluebutterfly


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 11

the_jon_m - bluesman of the parish

gets my vote !!

tjm


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 12

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

email sent. smiley - mouse


A3431170 - Cuttlefish - Sepia officinalis

Post 13

Lanzababy - Guide Editor

I think I could finish this one smiley - smiley

smiley - weird


Key: Complain about this post