A Conversation for Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
Peer Review: A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
alberto Lupi Started conversation Aug 10, 2010
Entry: Italia, etymology - ITALY (name) - A72812108
Author: alberto Lupi - U14576424
I hope to be correct!
A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
BMT Posted Aug 11, 2010
Hi Alberto, welcome to PR.
On first read can't see a lot wrong with this.
In this section you state:-
"In the humble opinion of he writer the Oscan> Greek> Latin seems to be the most probable."
Is this your opinion or the opinion of another writer/scholar? If it's your personal opinion then unless you can substantiate it, then we wouldn't allow it in an Edited Article.
Articles written for the Edited Guide have to be factually correct and not include personal references and/or opinion.
There are some house style issues etc but we can deal with those later.
BMT Scout
A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
h5ringer Posted Sep 16, 2010
Unfortunately the author hasn't posted since this appeared in PR. I think it stands more chance for getting into the Guide than his other entry posted at the same time, but it would need a fair amount of rewording to be acceptable. Could this go to FM and be picked up by a passing kindly angel?
Thoughts Scouts.
A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned Posted Sep 16, 2010
It needs a complete rewrite, but it could give someone a boost to write an Entry.
FM for me, too 
lil xx
A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
Lanzababy - Guide Editor Posted Sep 16, 2010
...and me
Lanzababy
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review: A72812108 - Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
More Conversations for Italia, etymology - ITALY (name)
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."