A Conversation for Good Charlotte- the band

Peer Review: A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 1

Shaz

Entry: Good Charlotte - A2438813
Author: kerry15 - U646110

I think I've written this entry really well, based on my knowledge of this band. This entry is informative and I hope it gets reviewed because there are no entries about Good Charlotte. I decided to write one.


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 2

Number Six

Good start smiley - ok

Two things spring to mind... firstly, do you know what Chris the drummer's surname is, and secondly, would you be able to make a stab at describing or classifying the kind of music they play?

I'm kind of aware of them having recently downloaded a whole bunch of punky cover versions off Bearshare, and is usual with these things you can get the same song labelled as being done by about three or four different bands depending on where you get it... so one or two of them may or may not be by Good Charlotte!

smiley - mod


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 3

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

The "eight years ago" will have to go, as it dates the entry. Just 1996 will do.

Any chance of a discography to add a bit more factual bulk?

Have they released any singles?

Nice start though, so don't be disheartened smiley - smiley

smiley - ale


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 4

Shaz

No, I don't know- I'd be grateful if someone told me, though. They are punk. Listen to their Young and Hopeless album- that should give you a feel.


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 5

Shaz

OK then. Have they released singles? Where have you been? (No rudeness intended). Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous, Girls and Boys, The Anthem, The Young and the Hopeless (the album's title track) and Hold On.

Discography? No idea. Sorry.


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 6

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

Where have I been? Listening to radios 2 and 4, chiefly.

That's good info, can you add it to the entry?

smiley - ale


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 7

.

I know it's a rather boring thing to do, but maybe it would help if you changed the title to "Good Charlotte - The Band". I had no idea what Good Charlotte was. (Where have I been? smiley - winkeye)


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 8

Shaz

Yo. I do know what Chris's surname is- Wilson.

Benjamin Madden
Joel Madden
Billy Martin
Paul Thomas
Chris Wilson

That's the full line up for ya.


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 9

GreyDesk

The author has abandoned her user account as it's "all screwed up".
But they've not left a link to a new account.

In the light of this abandonment, I propose a move back to entry for this.


A2438813 - Good Charlotte

Post 10

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

Seconded.


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Good Charlotte- the band

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more