A Conversation for Penny Mellor
Writing Workshop: A2072080 - Penny Mellor
leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] Started conversation Dec 5, 2003
Entry: Penny Mellor - A2072080
Author: leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] - U534308
more added re Penny Mellor/ msbp
A2072080 - Penny Mellor
Geggs Posted Dec 16, 2003
Don't know where to start on this.
Firstly, the way this entry is presented comes across as a hachet job. I get the impression that you don't like Penny Mellor and are trying to discredit her. If that is not the case then I apologise, but it does look like it's a personal attack.
Secondly, following the overturn of another 'cot-death' trial last week, there was some discussion in the media over whether MSBP actually exists or not. Some arguing that it is an unproven theory, other saying that certain person have admitted acting out MSBP towards their children.
So, the entry I would actually like to see is a balanced reckoning on MSBP which shows all (or just some if there's too many) of the arguements for and against MSBP. Clearly, it would be impossible to come to a decision at the end of it, because no decision has yet been made.
Would you be able to do *that* entry? Or do you think the honour should go to someone else?
Geggs
A2072080 - Penny Mellor
leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] Posted Dec 16, 2003
the trial evidence doesn't cast any light on the entity of MSBP. it casts doubt on the diagnosis in certain situations
A2072080 - Penny Mellor
leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] Posted Dec 16, 2003
the main thrust of this article is penny mellor's persecution of david southall - the roy meadows issue is now mentioned in a bit more detail. my entry was prompted by a conversation with someone falsely accused of MSBP who can't stand penny mellor ( and there are several others)
A2072080 - Penny Mellor
leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] Posted Dec 20, 2003
can someone tell me what is wrong with this article? I have made changes but without knowing what the problem is how can I get anywhere?
Key: Complain about this post
Writing Workshop: A2072080 - Penny Mellor
- 1: leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] (Dec 5, 2003)
- 2: Geggs (Dec 16, 2003)
- 3: leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] (Dec 16, 2003)
- 4: leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] (Dec 16, 2003)
- 5: leo mckern [space for random exotic word juxtaposition generator] (Dec 20, 2003)
More Conversations for Penny Mellor
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."