A Conversation for Editorial Feedback
EF King James
Recumbentman Started conversation Aug 12, 2016
A87874889
The second paragraph contains a mislead: "His grandson James VI of Scotland" refers not to the last male named (Henry VII) but to the one in an earlier sentence (James IV).
The ambiguity would be removed by putting it:
"Stewart's grandson, James VI of Scotland"
EF King James
Recumbentman Posted Aug 12, 2016
...though if you introduce my comma, you'd need another, thus:
Stewart's grandson, James VI of Scotland,
EF King James
Recumbentman Posted Aug 13, 2016
There still seems to be something wrong with the generations. The paragraph in question says that James VI was the grandson of James IV ( or worse, in its original form before we just corrected it, it suggested that James VI was the grandson of Henry VII).
The subsequent sentences however suggest that James IV was the great-grandfather of James VI:
James IV begat
James V, who begat
Mary, mother of
James VI. A glance at Wiki confirms this.
So we seem to need to add "great-" to the corrected sentence.
EF King James
Recumbentman Posted Aug 13, 2016
There is a non-sentence under the subheader "Mary Queen of Scots":
Raised in France to be the wife of the young Dauphin, who briefly became King Francis II of France (1559-1560) but died at the age of 16.
This lacks a principal verb. I suggest:
She was raised in France to be the wife of the young Dauphin, who briefly became King Francis II of France (1559-1560) but died at the age of 16.
Key: Complain about this post
EF King James
More Conversations for Editorial Feedback
- EF: A87893761 In Praise of the Heroic Theme Song: An Anglo-American TV Adventure [3]
Jul 24, 2024 - EF: A88031388 The Murdering Minister [6]
Feb 13, 2024 - A87877138 Le Chambon-sur-Lignon, a Village that Saved Jews [6]
Aug 22, 2023 - EF: A60698262 The Gaffney Peachoid [8]
Jun 4, 2023 - EF: A16442868 Rosemary's Baby, the Film [3]
May 4, 2023
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."