A Conversation for Talking Point: Life's Little Dilemmas
A treatise on ethical principles
Researcher 222000 Started conversation Mar 24, 2003
While Principles (with a capital P) provide absolute solutions to ethical dilemmas, they frequently fail to provide the solutions we want. And furthermore, having a principle dictating, say, chocolate consumption would be a bit silly.
Guidelines are principles stripped of their absolutist nature. They don't end arguments: they provide a jumping-off point. Say you're choosing how much to drink on a certain night. While Moderation is a principle that would result in greatly diminished enjoyment of a stag party, the guideline of moderation leads naturally to the happy solution of "moderation in moderation," leaving plenty of wiggle room for an enjoyable night.
While an appeal to principles trumps all other arguments, guidelines are vulnerable to handy conditional statements.
Some examples:
"...unless it's REALLY good chocolate."
"...unless it's been a bad day."
For the less ethical of us, there's also:
"...unless she's really hot"
"...unless no one is looking."
So for those of us who don't aspire to be the next Budda, Ghandi or Martin Luther King Jr., I suggest Guidelines as a substitute. They're just as helpful as principles, and a lot more flexible.
A treatise on ethical principles
KWDave Posted Mar 24, 2003
Hear, Hear! This does seem to take into account that man is human, after all, subject to the foibles of choice and free will. Having Principles in this mad world will likely drive you starkers, and besides, they're often very expensive to maintain. Guidelines seem much, much more do-able.
Key: Complain about this post
A treatise on ethical principles
More Conversations for Talking Point: Life's Little Dilemmas
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."