A Conversation for Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Peer Review: A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 1

G

Entry: Butlins, conception and pleated skirts. - A880553
Author: G - U209725

I wrote this in response to yesterdays (21/11/02) entry about Butlins, and felt that the first piece, combined with this would work well together.


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 2

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

Wow, what a story smiley - bigeyes Very nicely written too smiley - smiley

"This is the first piece I have posted, and hope that I am doing this correctly"

Unfortunately not. Peer review is intended for entries which are being written for submission to the edited section of h2g2 and which will end up on the front page, like the entry which inspired you. You can find details of the guidelines here Writing-Guidelines. This page will help you out too Writing-Beginners. Your entry can't be considered for the Edited Guide because it falls foul of the 'Write only in third person' rule. As a personal story it's hard to imagine how this could be re-written to accomodate that rule smiley - erm

Don't despair though - this is exactly the kind of thing which <./>ThePost</.> love to publish, and with a writing style as good as yours, I'd be very surprised if they didn't jump at this one.

And don't feel shy about writing more pieces which fit in with the guidelines - we'd love to see you here again smiley - ok


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 3

G

Thanks for the feedback. Following instructions have never been my strong point as my collection of Airfix models show. Each ended up like a paperweight whose substrate was glue as opposed to glass, with something quite, but not entireley disimilar to an aeroplane in the middle.

They did have a unique, if somewhat opaque charm though.

Third person only from now on.

Graham


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 4

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

*nods in agreement with Gosho*

Great piece, though! smiley - smiley As a child I dreamed of going to Butlins. We went to digs.

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 5

Gubernatrix

Hi there,

Just wanted to add my compliments on your writing style and to say that even though its not suitable for the EG, your piece was an enjoyable read. smiley - ok

Looking forward to your next entry!

Gubernatrix


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 6

Spiff

Hi there, G, smiley - ok

lovely piece, smiley - cheers, and as has been said, not EG, but hey, that's not the be-all; don't change a comma! smiley - yikes

and feel free to write all the first person stuff you like, and drop into the Alternative writing workshop, where anything goes, and this would be more than welcome. It's quieter than peer review generally, but the more stuff like this there is, the more people will want to read and comment on the entries that go in there.

and i agree about The Post, but if you want an easy way in, i'd love to run this in the weekly CAC column there some time soon. smiley - smiley

so, thanks for this one, looking forward with the others to the next, smiley - ok
spiff


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 7

G

As I am as talented with technology as I am with instructions, I may have some diificulty in working out how to submit the piece. If this helps you understand my limitations with things digital, my video recorder has been blinking 12.00, 12.00, 12.00 constantly since 1982.

I have since edited the piece, so I have to redo the upload thingy. I will see if I can find where to post it, but if on your journey through cybespace you come accross some incongruous analogue chalk marks with an arrow and the initials GS, you will know what has happened.

Graham


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 8

Post Team

Ahah smiley - smiley

Thanks to ~jwf~ I have found you! I wanted to run your piece this week in <./>ThePost</.> but you didn't include your h2g2 name, only your real one, and we are reluctant to publish anything without this information. Your piece arrived safely but I couldn't decipher your email address so was stymied.

If you are still happy for us to use this it will appear next week. I have taken onboard a few of the comments here and from ~jwf~ and may add a few footnotes to explain the 'very British' sections - or put in a link to the edited entry on Butlins smiley - smiley

shazz smiley - thepost


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 9

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

Hello Shazz, long time no see smiley - hug How's it going?

Ok, since this is going to grace The Post (hoorah), and since the author has acknowledged submitting it to the wrong forum, may I propose a move back to entry for this one smiley - smiley

Seconders?


A880553 - Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Post 10

Monsignore Pizzafunghi Bosselese

yup, here smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Butlins, conception and pleated skirts.

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more