Copy of Plato - Philosopher: On Atlantis

0 Conversations

Plato - Philosopher:
Introduction
On Socrates |
The Republic
On Love |
On Atlantis |
On Politics

One of the most interesting things about the philosopher Plato is that in the Fourth Century BC he made the first recorded reference to Atlantis, the legendary island that sank into the sea. The work was originally planned to be a trilogy, but unfortunately it was never completed. The three parts are: Timaeus (completed), Critias (partially finished), and a third work that was never started.

Timaeus

Timaeus, Critias and Hermocrates were real people who had an interest in philosophy and politics. The book Timaeus describes their dialogue with the philosopher Socrates, in which they talk about history, mathematics and science.

At first, though, Critias tells Socrates the tale his grandfather had told to him, and which had been told to him by the Athenian political leader Solon, who had learned of the story from an Egyptian priest. The priest explained that Athens had been founded by the goddess Athena 9,000 years earlier, but a great flood had destroyed the history of the city, including the knowledge of the Athenians' war against the people of Atlantis. The Egyptian city of Sais had been founded 8,000 years earlier and it escaped from the flood, being a hot, dry place, so the history of Atlantis had been preserved.

Atlantis is described as a huge island situated near the Pillars of Hercules with the Mediterranean Sea to one side of it, and the Atlantic Ocean to the other side of it. The Atlanteans were fighting against the warriors of all the Mediterranean nations, but it was the Athenians who defeated them. After the battle, there were earthquakes and the Athenian warriors, plus the whole of the island of Atlantis, sank into the sea.

Critias

The book Critias continues the dialogue of Timaeus, and describes the island and the war between Athens and Atlantis in more detail. The ancient Athenians were described as model citizens - beautiful, virtuous and hard working.

Poseidon was the god who founded Atlantis - he fell in love with Cleito, a mortal who lived in a mountain, and he formed the mountain into a circular island, surrounded by a ring of water, which in turn was surrounded by a ring of land. He fathered five sets of twins with Cleito and they and their children became the inhabitants of Atlantis - the island and the Atlantic Ocean were named after Atlas, their first-born child.

Atlantis was a lush place, providing everything that the inhabitants needed and wanted, including plentiful food and substantial wealth. Over time, temples were constructed1, then a palace, plus bridges to the outer ring of land. Next a canal was dug from the inner island, through the outer ring, out to the sea, and docks and ships were built. Thousands of Atlanteans were trained in military ways - some were horsemen or archers and others were sailors in the fleet of 1,200 ships.

Poseidon had given the people of Atlantis a set of laws, which were inscribed on to pillars, and the kings of the island regions met by the pillars every five or six years to dispense justice if necessary. At first, the people were virtuous, but their descendants, who became more mortal with each generation as Poseidon's blood became diluted in them, started to become greedy and 'intoxicated by luxury'. Zeus decided they should be punished so that they would improve their behaviour in future.

Unfortunately, the text ends there, so it is not known what happened next and why the whole island was destroyed completely, taking the Athenian warriors with it. The story of the fabulous island that sank beneath the waves has captured the imaginations of many people ever since, though.

Atlantis the Legend

Plato's tale explained why the mouth of the Mediterranean Sea was so shallow and muddy, but since his time, many other people have set out their theories about Atlantis. Some say it never existed, and was just made up by Plato for use in his philosophical teaching, and others say that it did exist and Plato was reporting historical fact.

Suggestions about the location of Atlantis range from New Zealand to Switzerland and even Antarctica. One argument was that instead of west of the Pillars of Hercules, Atlantis lay to the east and was in fact the island of Crete. It was once a prosperous island, which was host to part of the Minoan Empire. Then suddenly the Empire was gone. Santorini, just north of Crete, is now a ring of islands but was once one island with a volcano in the centre. When the volcano erupted, the effect was four times as powerful as Krakatoa. The resulting tsunami that would have hit Crete could have travelled inland for over half a mile and would have destroyed towns and cities. Equally, Santorini itself, also part of the Minoan Empire, could have been Atlantis. If the fall of the Minoan Empire is the true story of Atlantis rather than a Atlantis being a myth, the natural question is how Plato got the location and time so wrong. In 1969, the book 'Atlantis: The truth behind the legend' suggested there could have been a mistake during translation of some of the numbers, meaning the dates of the events were actually much more recent and, rather than Atlantis being bigger than Libya and Asia, the island could have been between Libya and Asia.

There is another theory that Ireland may be Atlantis. The claim is made by a geologist named Ulf Erlingsson in his book 'Atlantis from a Geographer’s Perspective: Mapping the Fairy Land'. Ulf says Plato's description of Atlantis matches Ireland perfectly: 'The probability is over 99.98% that Plato was describing Ireland.' He reckoned that Ireland is about the same size and shape as Plato said, plus it faces the Atlantic Ocean on one side. Rather than the island in the Atlantic and the sunken island being one and the same, Ulf suggests that the story of Atlantis mixed up two tales, linking Ireland with Dogger Bank in the North Sea that sank under flood waves in about 6100 BC.

Whatever the truth, the island of Atlantis and Plato's descriptions of it have provided fascination for hundreds of years.

1With the most richly decorated in gold and silver being the temple to Poseidon.

Bookmark on your Personal Space


Conversations About This Entry

There are no Conversations for this Entry

Entry

A87812931

Infinite Improbability Drive

Infinite Improbability Drive

Read a random Edited Entry


Written and Edited by

Disclaimer

h2g2 is created by h2g2's users, who are members of the public. The views expressed are theirs and unless specifically stated are not those of the Not Panicking Ltd. Unlike Edited Entries, Entries have not been checked by an Editor. If you consider any Entry to be in breach of the site's House Rules, please register a complaint. For any other comments, please visit the Feedback page.

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more